Nootropic forums and blogs often describe depression as a neurotransmitter imbalance in the brain. And then offer suggestions on various nootropics to help lift mood and banish depression.
But this simplistic view of depression misses the complexity of this disease. Recent research has shown that depression can have many possible causes. Including out of whack mood regulation by the brain, genetic problems, stressful events, prescription medications and medical problems.
It’s true that neurotransmitters are involved in the process that contributes to depression. But it’s usually not a matter of one neurotransmitter being too low and another too high.
Instead, you have several neurotransmitters, amino acids, hormones and other neurochemicals working both inside and outside neurons.
The interaction of these neurochemical reactions make up a highly dynamic system that is responsible for your mood. And how you perceive and experience life.
With this level of complexity, you may have similar symptoms of depression to the person next to you. But the issues in your brain and body may be completely different. So what works best for someone else experiencing your symptoms may not be best for you.
And this is why we often say in the nootropic community that Your Mileage May Vary (YMMV) when describing a particular nootropic supplement. And how it feels.
Table of Contents
Depression and Neurogenesis
It turns out that neuron connections, neurogenesis and the function of neuronal circuits may play a more important role in depression than levels of neurotransmitters.
For example, researchers in Munich studied 24 women who had a history of depression. And on average, the hippocampus was 9 – 13% smaller in depressed women compared to healthy women. And the more bouts of depression a woman had, the smaller the hippocampus.[i]
We know that stress plays a role in depression. And research has shown that stress can suppress neurogenesis. Which would account for the smaller hippocampus in these women.
We also know that Brain-Derived Neurotrophic Factor (BDNF), a naturally occurring protein, is critical for preventing apoptosis (brain cell death), growth of new neurons (neurogenesis) and growth of synapses.
Please check out this article on “13 Nootropics to Boost BDNF”. Increasing BDNF is one way to combat depression. And you’ll see some parallel between the nootropics listed below. And the list of nootropics used for boosting BDNF.
If you’ve ever tried antidepressants, you know that it often takes weeks to feel any benefit. Scientists have a theory that the value of these medications may be in generating new neurons (neurogenesis), strengthening neuron connections, and improving neural signaling.
So now researchers speculate that new medications could be developed that specifically promote neurogenesis. As it turns out, we already have this ability with several natural nootropic supplements.
Depression and Neurotransmitters
Now that we know that neurotransmitters are not the only critical part of preventing depression. We can’t discount their importance either.
Neurons are specifically designed to communicate with each other. When a neuron is activated, it passes an ‘action potential’ down its axon to the axon terminal. Neurotransmitters are stored in vesicles in this terminal.
The action potential (signal) releases certain neurotransmitters into the synapse (space between neurons). And on to the dendrite of the receiving neuron. As the concentration of neurotransmitters rise in the synapse, they bind to receptors embedded in the membranes of the two neurons.
This release of a neurotransmitter from one neuron can activate or inhibit the second neuron. Once the first neuron has released a certain amount of neurotransmitter, a feedback mechanism instructs the neuron to stop putting out this neurotransmitter and begin bringing it back into the 1st neuron. This process is called reuptake.
In those who are severely depressed or manic, this fine-tuned system of neuro-signaling goes out of whack. Either too much or too little of the neurotransmitter is released.
Or if the reuptake is overly efficient and mops up too many neurotransmitter molecules before they have a chance to bind to receptors. It can have a significant impact on mood.
The primary neurotransmitters that play a role in depression include:
Each one of these neurotransmitters can be boosted, or their reuptake affected by nootropic supplements (listed below).
Depression and Prescription Medication
Depression is often a side effect of certain prescription drugs. These drugs include; antimicrobials, antibiotics, antifungals, antivirals, heart and blood pressure drugs, hormones, insomnia drugs, tranquilizers, antacids, narcotic pain drugs and more.
We know from experience that many of these prescription drugs can be replaced by safer, natural alternatives. Like nootropic supplements.
But I am NOT encouraging you to stop using whatever meds you’re currently on. Without consulting with your doctor first. I am encouraging you to seek out safer alternatives that often do the job just as well.
Depression and Stress
Nearly all of us experience stressful events. And while not everyone of us who faces stress develops depressive disorder. Stress does play an important role in depression.
Depending on how sensitive you are to stress, along with messed up neurochemistry and even genetics. A perfect storm of any or all of these influencing factors can lead to depression.
So please check out my extended article on “Best Nootropics for Anxiety” which includes several nootropic supplements that help you deal with and conquer stress.
Recommended Nootropics for Depression
If you are currently being treated for depression. Or suspect you may be dealing with undiagnosed depression. And are looking for a more natural, safer way to treat your symptoms. Nootropics could be the answer.
You’re not alone looking for an alternative to drugs that come with a host of side effects. Research in the United States and other countries show that significant numbers of people use ‘alternative medicine’ to treat their depression.
Researchers conducted a survey of more than 3,000 women in the USA to find out how many turned to alternative medicine for depression. Of the 220 women who said they had been officially diagnosed with depression, 54% said they used alternative medicine to treat their symptoms.[ii]
We have found that the following list of nootropics work well for different types and causes of depression.
As I mentioned before, your mileage may vary. What works for me may not work for you. Wise and careful experimentation is critical to finding a safer alternative for treating your depression.
- Aniracetam – A member of the racetam-family of nootropics, Aniracetam works with dopamine D2 and D3 receptors in your brain. And desensitizes AMPA (glutamate) receptors.
Aniracetam is one of the most effective antidepressants I’ve even tried. And its effects on dopamine in your brain can have a profound effect on anxiety symptoms as well.
- Bacopa Monnieri – One of the most powerful herbs in Ayurvedic healing. Bacopa has been used for millennia to relieve anxiety, fatigue, restore energy and boost concentration.
This adaptogen has been shown in clinical studies to work as well for depression as benzodiazepines and tricyclic antidepressants.[iii]
- Coenzyme Q10 (CoQ10) – CoQ10 is your cell’s natural source of energy. Fueling your mitochondria by taking fat and converting it into usable energy. CoQ10 preserves brain function, helps fight mental illness and migraines.
Major depression, bipolar disorder and schizophrenia are now being recognized as having mitochondrial dysfunction in common. With higher oxidative stress levels.[iv] Studies show that 1,200 mg per day of CoQ10 in bipolar adults experienced a significant reduction in depression.[v]
- 5-HTP – I do NOT recommend using 5-HTP for treating depression. But thought to include it here since it is promoted as a “natural antidepressant”.
This amino acid is naturally produced in your body. And synthesized from the amino acid tryptophan which we get from food. 5-HTP is the precursor needed to produce the ‘feel-good’ neurotransmitter serotonin. But a summary published by the Alternative Medicine Review noted a lack of evidence for ‘loading’ precursors to treat depression.[vi] Combining 5-HTP with SSRI’s, Tricyclics or MAOI’s will cause Serotonin Syndrome. And the side effects on its own are nasty. Or even deadly.
- Ginkgo Biloba – This tree native to China has been used for thousands of years to boost mental alertness, improve cerebral circulation and for overall brain function. Many have found Ginkgo to be very effective in reducing anxiety and stress. And for boosting mood.
1,570 men and women in England participated in a study using 120 mg of Ginkgo Biloba extract daily for 4, 6, and 10 months. Those who used Gingko the longest experienced the most improvement in ratings for anxiety, depression, energy, drowsiness, sadness and happiness.[vii]
- Iodine – Did you know that iodine deficient populations are up to 13.5 IQ points less than normal people?[viii] Since iodine has largely been removed from table salt in some countries, it has been suggested that iodine deficiency is epidemic. Particularly in countries like the United States.
Iodine is essential to thyroid health. And nearly every tissue in your body relies on thyroid hormones. Not enough iodine can result in hypothyroidism. Negatively affecting acetylcholine synthesis in your brain. Affecting cognition, memory, learning, recall and mood.
- Kava – Kava is native to the South Pacific. And the islanders use kava for its sedative effects. Kava can help reduce anxiety and depression. Unlike benzodiazepines, kava does not impair cognitive function. In fact, studies show that not only will it improve mood. But may boost cognitive function as well.[ix]
- Lion’s Mane Mushroom – Also called the “smart mushroom”, Lion’s Mane boosts brain nerve growth factor which increases neurogenesis. Lion’s Mane can help improve focus and attention, boost thinking, repair brain cells, and help anxiety and depression.
Women in Japan received Lion’s Mane-laced cookies for 4 weeks during a clinical trial. The researchers found that Lion’s Mane reduced anxiety and depression in these women during the trial.[x]
- Magnesium – Lack of adequate magnesium can result in brain fog, anxiety and depression. Plasticity of neuron synapses is affected by the presence of adequate magnesium in brain cells.
A study was conducted with 5,708 people in Norway. The aim of the study was to examine the association between magnesium intake and depression and anxiety. The researchers found that low magnesium intake is related to depression.[xi]
- Mucuna Pruriens (L-DOPA) – L-DOPA is synthesized from the amino acid tyrosine in your body. And is a precursor to the formation of dopamine, epinephrine and norepinephrine in your brain.
Mucuna Pruriens has been used in Ayurveda medicine since 1500 B.C. For treating things like snakebite, intestinal problems, sexual issues and melancholy mood. Research shows that supplementing with L-DOPA as Mucuna Pruriens extract is a great natural antidepressant.[xii]
- N-Acetyl L-Cysteine (NAC) – NAC is an amino acid that regulates the amount of glutamate and dopamine in your brain. And is a precursor to glutathione which reduces free radicals.
A study with 75 subjects with bipolar disorder were given 1 gram of NAC twice daily for 24 weeks. Treatment with NAC caused a significant improvement with depression in these patients.[xiii]
- N-Acetyl L-Tyrosine (NALT) – NALT is a highly bioavailable form of the amino acid L-Tyrosine. Your brain uses tyrosine to produce dopamine and norepinephrine. Dopamine is involved in libido, memory, focus, goal-oriented concentration, a mood elevator and antidepressant.
If you are ADHD, or have other issues with low dopamine, supplementing with NALT may help improve your memory, boost your IQ, and relieve depression. I highly recommend NALT for anyone using stimulants like Adderall or Ritalin for treating ADHD.
- Nefiracetam – One of the newer members of the racetam-family of nootropics, Nefiracetam is used clinically to treat and prevent seizures, severe depression and has shown neuroprotective qualities.
The structure of Nefiracetam is similar to the other great racetam antidepressant Aniracetam. Researchers at the University of Iowa did a trial with 159 stroke patients with major depression. The study concluded that Nefiracetam produced a significant improvement in the most severely depressed patients.[xiv]
- Noopept – This peptide-derived nootropic related to the racetam-family is much more potent than Piracetam. But its mechanism of action in your brain is similar to other racetams.
Noopept stimulates dopamine, nicotinic and serotonin receptors. And boosts cognition, memory, logical thinking, reflexes and mood.[xv] Noopept increases Alpha and Beta brain waves. Increasing relaxation. And moving you into super-learning, flow states and joy.
- Phenylalanine – This amino acid is a precursor to tyrosine in your brain. Tyrosine helps in the formation and utilization of dopamine, epinephrine, norepinephrine and melatonin.
One study was done with 23 patients diagnosed with depression who had not responded to standard antidepressants. They were given 50 or 100 mg of Phenylalanine daily for 15 days. The researchers found that Phenylalanine completely improved mood in 17 of the patients. Within 13 days of the 15-day trial.[xvi]
- Rhodiola Rosea – Rhodiola activates AMPA receptors in your brain. Which decreases depression and stress-related mood swings, reduces fatigue, stimulates energy and alertness, and boosts cognition.
A clinical trial with 57 patients diagnosed with depression were given Rhodiola Rosea extract, sertraline (Zoloft®), or a placebo for 12 weeks. The study found that Rhodiola was slightly less effective than sertraline for depression. But produced far fewer side effects and was better tolerated.[xvii]
- SAM-e – SAM-e is the naturally occurring amino acid methionine bound to an ATP molecule. It helps in the process of cell division and repair, and the generation of the neurotransmitters dopamine, serotonin, norepinephrine and melatonin. Which is why it’s considered a potent nootropic.
SAM-e is used to boost mood, relieve depression, improve energy levels and reduce symptoms of fibromyalgia. 20 healthy volunteers took part in a study receiving infusions of 800 mg of SAM-e or a placebo for 7 days. EEG mapping during the study identified SAM-e as an antidepressant. Targeting brain regions crucial in the therapeutic efficacy of antidepressants.[xviii]
- St. John’s wort – This plant has traditionally been used for mood disorders and wound healing. Today it’s used mostly as a treatment for anxiety, depression and stress.
St. John’s wort works like prescription SSRI’s by preventing the reuptake of serotonin in your brain. But please read the precautions for using this nootropic in the extended article. Before trying it as a nootropic supplement to treat your depression.
- Sulbutiamine – Sulbutiamine is a synthesized version of Vitamin B1 (thiamine) which easily crosses the blood-brain barrier. As a nootropic, it’s taken to boost mood, memory and motivation.
A study at the University of Wales Swansea in the UK worked with 120 young adult females. Study participants took either a placebo or 50 mg thiamine for 2 months. Mood, memory and reaction times were monitored before and after taking the tablets. 2 months after supplementing with thiamine, participants were more clearheaded, felt more composed and energetic, reaction times improved, and mood was better.[xix]
- Tryptophan – This essential amino acid is a precursor to serotonin and melatonin and niacin (Vitamin B3) in your body. Adding tryptophan to your stack can help boost your serotonin levels. And should help with anxiety, ADHD, depression, insomnia, memory loss, pain and eating disorders.
- Turmeric– Turmeric is one of the main spices in curries. In parts of India where curries are eaten most often, Alzheimer’s disease is extremely rare. This spice (and its extract called curcumin) has a unique ability to reduce inflammation common to Parkinson’s, Alzheimer’s and brain tumors.
A study conducted in India looked at the efficacy and safety of using curcumin, one of the active ingredients found in turmeric, for treating major depression.
60 depressed patients took either 20 mg of Prozac®, 1000 mg of curcumin, or a combination of both daily for 6 weeks. The best response during the trial was with patients using the two. And the researchers concluded that curcumin could be used as an effective and safe treatment for patients with major depression.
- Uridine Monophosphate – This precursor to Ribonucleic Acid (RNA) provides instructions to your DNA to help create memory by facilitating connections between brain neurons (synapses).
Uridine supplementation as a nootropic uplifts and stabilizes mood, is anti-stress, helps Obsessive Compulsive Disorder, is anti-anxiety and helps modulate and normalize dopamine release.[xx]
- Vitamin B6 – Vitamin B6 helps your brain make serotonin, norepinephrine and melatonin. The activated form of Vitamin B6 called P-5-P is particularly effective in boosting serotonin and GABA in your brain.
For depression, look for a P-5-P supplement or a B-Complex formula that uses P-5-P.
- Vitamin B12 – This B-vitamin plays a key role in the efficient conversion of carbohydrates to glucose – your cell’s source of fuel. It also helps your body convert fatty acids into energy.
Supplementing with Vitamin B12 can help lower anxiety, and elevate alertness, cognition, energy, vision, elevate mood and relieve insomnia. No more mood swings!
Depressed No More
Nootropics are a strong alternative to many antidepressant medications currently prescribed by doctors. And promoted by the Big Pharmaceutical companies.
But a very strong word of caution – if you are currently using any prescription antidepressant medications. Or any medication for that matter. Research each nootropic including side effects and prescription drug interactions before using them.
To finally beat depression, you must figure out the root cause of it. It is pointless to try otherwise without doing your research. And experimenting with various nootropic supplements until you find out what works for you.
Good luck in your search. There is hope. I know because I’ve conquered my depression. And come out the other side better than before.
[i] Frodl T. et. Al. “Reduced hippocampal volume correlates with executive dysfunctioning in major depression” Journal of Psychiatry and Neuroscience 2006 Sep; 31(5): 316–325. (source)
[ii] “Alternative medicine for depression” Harvard Medical School July 1, 2007 (source)
[iii] Bhattacharya S.K., Bhattacharya A., Sairam K., “Ghosal S. Anxiolytic-antidepressant activity of Withania somnifera glycowithanolides: an experimental study.” Phytomedicine 2000 Dec;7(6):463-9. (source)
[iv] Maes M., Galecki P., Chang Y.S., Berk M. “ A review on the oxidative and nitrosative stress (O&NS) pathways in major depression and their possible contribution to the (neuro)degenerative processes in that illness.” Progress in Neuropsychopharmacology and Biological Psychiatry. 2011 Apr 29;35(3):676-92. (source)
[v] Forester B.P., Zuo C.S., Ravichandran C., Harper D.G., Du F., Kim S., Cohen B.M., Renshaw P.F. “Coenzyme Q10 effects on creatine kinase activity and mood in geriatric bipolar depression.” Journal of Geriatric Psychiatry and Neurology. 2012 Mar;25(1):43-50. (source)
[vi] Meyers S. “Use of neurotransmitter precursors for treatment of depression.” Alternative Medicine Revue. 2000 Feb;5(1):64-71. (source)
[vii] Trick L., Boyle J., Hindmarch I. “The effects of Ginkgo biloba extract (LI 1370) supplementation and discontinuation on activities of daily living and mood in free living older volunteers.” Phytotherapy Research. 2004 Jul;18(7):531-7. (source)
[viii] Qian M., Wang D., Watkins W.E., Gebski V., Yan Y.Q., Li M., Chen Z.P. “The effects of iodine on intelligence in children: a meta-analysis of studies conducted in China.” Asia Pacific Journal of Clinical Nutrition 2005;14(1):32-42. (source)
[ix] Thompson R., Ruch W., Hasenöhrl R.U. “Enhanced cognitive performance and cheerful mood by standardized extracts of Piper methysticum (Kava-kava). Human Psychopharmacology. 2004 Jun;19(4):243-50. (source)
[x] Nagano M., Shimizu K., Kondo R., Hayashi C., Sato D., Kitagawa K., Ohnuki K. “Reduction of depression and anxiety by 4 weeks Hericium erinaceus intake.” Biomedical Research. 2010 Aug;31(4):231-7. (source)
[xi] Jacka F.N. et. Al. “ Association between magnesium intake and depression and anxiety in community-dwelling adults: the Hordaland Health Study” Australian and New Zealand Journal of Psychiatry Volume 43, Issue 1, 2009 (source)
[xii] Rana D.G., Galani V.J. “Dopamine mediated antidepressant effect of Mucuna pruriens seeds in various experimental models of depression.” Ayu. 2014 Jan;35(1):90-7. (source)
[xiii] Berk M., Copolov D.L., Dean O., Lu K., Jeavons S, Schapkaitz I., Anderson-Hunt M., Bush A.I. “N-acetyl cysteine for depressive symptoms in bipolar disorder–a double-blind randomized placebo-controlled trial.” Biological Psychiatry. 2008 Sep 15;64(6):468-75 (source)
[xiv] Robinson R.G., Jorge R.E., Clarence-Smith K. “Double-blind randomized treatment of poststroke depression using nefiracetam.” Journal of Neuropsychiatry and Clinical Neurosciences. 2008 Spring;20(2):178-84. (source)
[xv] Gudasheva T.A., Konstantinopol’skii M.A., Ostrovskaya R.U., Seredenin S.B. “Anxiolytic activity of endogenous nootropic dipeptide cycloprolylglycine in elevated plus-maze test.” Bulletin of Experimental Biology and Medicine. 2001 May;131(5):464-6. (source)
[xvi] Fischer E., Heller B., Nachon M., Spatz H. “Therapy of depression by phenylalanine. Preliminary note.” Arzneimittelforschung. 1975 Jan;25(1):132. (source)
[xvii] Mao J.J., Xie S.X., Zee J., Soeller I., Li QS., Rockwell K., Amsterdam J.D. “Rhodiola rosea versus sertraline for major depressive disorder: A randomized placebo-controlled trial.” Phytomedicine. 2015 Mar 15;22(3):394-9. (source)
[xviii] Saletu B., Anderer P., Di Padova C., Assandri A., Saletu-Zyhlarz G.M. “Electrophysiological neuroimaging of the central effects of S-adenosyl-L-methionine by mapping of electroencephalograms and event-related potentials and low-resolution brain electromagnetic tomography.” American Journal of Clinical Nutrition. 2002 Nov;76(5):1162S-71S (source)
[xix] Benton D., Griffiths R., Haller J. “Thiamine supplementation mood and cognitive functioning.” Psychopharmacology 1997 Jan;129(1):66-71. (source)
[xx] Powell A. “Rx for depression: ‘Mangia, mangia!’ Harvard Gazette Archives new.harvard.edu March 03, 2005 Retrieved August 9, 2016 (source)
Hello David,
excellent site, gives me a lot of hope …
I’ve had depression for years. I’ve tried a lot of drugs and none of them really help …
I am currently taking prescribed Tianeptine sodium tablets 12,5 mg, 3 x 1, which only slightly help me not feel so bad. However, I still have no motivation. I’ve also added Ashwaganda to my regimen to help me fall asleep easier, but I have trouble waking up even after a 12-hour sleep.
I was thinking of starting Aniracetam. Is it safe to combine Tianeptine and Aniracetam together? I can‘t seem to find good info on that.
Maybe you can recommend me something else?
Thank you!
Kind regards
Mia
Mia, take a look at how tianeptine works here:https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tianeptine#Pharmacology. It affects opioid receptors, inhibits glutamate receptors, increases BDNF to improve neuroplasticity, enhances serotonin receptor response, enhances dopamine D2 & D3 receptors, and affects gene expression.
It would take 5 or 6 individual nootropic supplements to try and mimic how Tianeptine works. If you have no negative effects from this drug I’d continue using it if it works for you. Because the alternative it a little complicated.
Ashwagandha may be the wrong supplement for you. I can’t use it because it affects thyroid hormones and I am hypothyroid.
I’m hesitant to recommend ANYTHING to you because of how Tianeptine works. And I cannot find a list of contraindicated drugs either because it goes by several different names around the world.
Aniracetam also affects Dopamine D2 & D3 receptors which is a good thing. Unless you are using Tianeptine which does the same thing. I have no idea what would happen if you tried combining the two but it’s likely best not to find out.
Saffron (https://nootropicsexpert.com/saffron/) may be an option for you because it’s effective for depression and is not contraindicated with anything as far as I know.
Alternatives for sleep can be found here: https://nootropicsexpert.com/best-sleep-supplements-to-buy/
Can you recommend a nootropic for withdrawing from TCA type antidepressants? I am currently experience withdrawal symptoms as I’m slowly weaning off clomipramine.
Leyla, there is no nootropic to help reduce the withdrawal symptoms from antidepressants. Yes for opiates. But not for antidepressants.
And it’s because of at last two things; anything that works like a prescription antidepressant is contraindicated because it could cause Serotonin Syndrome or a heart attack. And because of the way antidepressants destroy your brain. Including messing with things like ion channels and gene expression. The only things that will repair that type of damage if it’s even possible is time.
Thank you for your reply, one month later I just saw it as I am still researching for some type of relief. As the TCA is still apparently in my system, is it best to avoid all nootropics at this point? Is there no hope for any type of repair?
Also, is it possible that the use of Alpha GPC is exasperating symptoms as TCA type antidepressants are well known anticholinergics?
Leyla, this is my response to you in the Alpha GPC thread,
“Leyla, based on that quote you shouldn’t be using Alpha GPC. Because that quote is saying you are already dealing with excess choline activity due to withdrawal from the drug.
Where did you find that quote? I’d like to read the entire study. Because a lot of people come here looking for answers on avoiding the severe side effects of antidepressant discontinuation withdrawal symptoms. And so far, I haven’t found an answer.”
David, my mental issues first started as extreme anger when I was about 6-9 years old. Then the anxiety with panic attacks started at about 10. When I hit 8th-9th grade the depression finally manifested itself. My childhood consists of the worst memories thus far, and I am 28 now. My mom has been taking Zoloft for 20+ years, my grandma (mom’s mom) Zoloft for god knows how long, and my little sis Lexapro for 5 years. I think it runs in the family lol. When I was 18 my mom finally took me to the doctor and he gave me Lexapro and it completely changed my life. I took this up until I graduated from college in 2016 and then tapered off. In a matter of a year, I was at probably the lowest point of my life. I picked myself back up and went back to the doctor. We experimented for 2 years and I finally ended up on a combination of Viibryd 40mg and Lamotrigine 100mg. This done well for about 2ish years but in the last 6 months my depression has slowly gotten worse with the inevitable feeling that this is not going away. I am 28 now with no wife, no kids, and bomb ass engineering job. But the depression does not care.
I remember during my experimental antidepressant journey that I responded ‘okay’ to this tricyclic antidepressant called Nortriptyline. I tried it for a few months and then we decided to move onto Viibryd. I have read that Norepinephrine is related to fight-or-flight. But I still to this day have pretty bad anger issues and I feel like that may be from too much Norepinephrine. I do not know if this would be a good place to start or not. Probably not.
However, If I feel that my ability to grow new neurons and/or replace bad ones is weak, what would be a good thing to start with? Aniracetam seems to be a popular well-reviewed one. Or, is there a stack that would be more likely to help? I feel like a stack is going to be hard to pinpoint what is/isn’t helpful though. Thoughts? Now I know that I need to be careful of the effects of prescription SSRIs and SNRIs with nootropics. I am not going to take anything without bringing this up to my doctor. Thanks in advance.
Daniel, I’ve found from working with other people that if you have used something like a SSRI or SNRI successfully you find out how it works. Figure out the mechanism of action in your brain that provided the benefit. Then reverse engineer this process and find a nootropic that does something similar.
I’ve found that Wikipedia is a good source for most best selling drugs that have been used for a long time. Each drug on Wikipedia typically has a section called “Pharmacology” which describes the mechanism of action. It could be a particular neurotransmitter like dopamine or norepinephrine. Or one if its receptors or transporters.
For example, you said that Lexapro changed your life. Wikipedia reports that “Escitalopram increases intrasynaptic levels of the neurotransmitter serotonin by blocking the reuptake of the neurotransmitter into the presynaptic neuron.”
So what would happen if you tried using L-Tryptophan to raise serotonin? Would that help? If it did then find other nootropics that influence serotonin.
David, I recently purchased Performance Labs Sleep and had such high hopes for it after having tried about everything available for insomnia. I took it for one night, per directions, and was awake the entire night. I also suffer from depression and anxiety. I have adrenal insufficiency and Hashimoto’s disease. I always have bad reactions to prescription psych meds. Any ideas? Also, this company offers refunds but I have been unable to get a direct response from them. Have received automated response telling me they are available 7/24 and would get back with me within 30 minutes, which they did not do. I spent a lot of money on this product and am a little concerned about their lack of response. So far, I have attempted to make contact with them 4 times. Any help, if you have it, would be appreciated.
Ellen, it can take 2 – 3 weeks of daily use of Performance Lab Sleep before you begin to get the full benefit from this stack. This is not Ambien. It’s not fair to try it one night and expect it to solve your life-long insomnia issues.
I’ll send a personal email to their Customer Service Manager and ask him to take care of you.
You’ve got Hashimoto’s, Adrenal fatigue, anxiety and depression. Each is a separate and complex health issue. The first two are fairly simple to know what to do because we know the cause.
But for anxiety and depression you first need to find out the cause of each. And then commit to weeks and possibly months of trial and error while trying different supplements to isolate the cause.
If you’re willing to do the work, these two articles may help you:
https://nootropicsexpert.com/best-nootropics-for-anxiety/
And the one above:
https://nootropicsexpert.com/best-nootropics-for-depression/
Hi David✌️
Spot on! I found what works for me as well. After battling depression for 20 some odd years.
I beat the oppressor!
Have a super day David, and stay safe.
That is great news Stephen! I hope this is encouragement to anyone who is still struggling. Keep at it and keep trying. Until you find something that works.
Hey Stephen,
Can you share your Stack with us?
Hi David,
Thank you for your work. I have had major depression and anxiety since I was 6 years old. I am presently 52. I went on depression medications five years ago. The last 2.5 years I ws on Abilify, Zoloft and Lamictal. I weaned off of all three under my psychiatrist’s watch. The last pill I took was on October 8. The past 10 months has been brutal, particularly with insomnia. The depression is bad as is the anxiety.
I have tried so many different supplements with the insomnia. I just started seeing a neurologist who is a sleep specialist. He recommends 2000 mg of Magnesium L-Threonate, 500 mgs of L-Tryptophan and 5 mgs of extended release melatonin. He practices Sleep Restriction Therapy. I started last night. It looks like it’s going to be a long, painful process. And that’s if it works.
I am looking for some guidance there but mostly with the depression. I believe it stems from emotional trauma i.e. developmental trauma. I just don’t know how much of it is “chemical” per se. I’m wondering what your thoughts are. I had tried 11 different depression medications over the 5 years. The three I weaned off of just numbed me, didn’t really do much for the emotional pain.
Thanks!
Gary, after all the research I’ve done for depression I’m convinced that the emotional part of depression manifests physically one way or another. And we can experience at least some relief if we can isolate that physical component. And treat it.
You’ve be battling depression for most of your life. So may I humbly suggest that you re-read this post from top to bottom with an open mind. And consider testing each theory.
For example, it could be a problem with neurogenesis and the ability to grow new neurons and replace damaged or faulty neurons. Or it could be a neurotransmitter imbalance. But the challenge is trying to figure out which neurotransmitter and its system is out of whack. Or it could be a problem with your microbiome which has a direct connection to your brain.
This may take awhile but only if you’re willing to experiment. And it looks like you are willing by reading your second paragraph. Go through each section and try a couple of nootropics that address that possible cause.
There is no guarantee of course that I’m right. Or that you’ll figure it out. But it’s what I had to do a couple of times in my adult life if I wanted to live. The last time it took me 2 1/2 years before I finally started to feel well again. But boy, was it worth it.
If you would like some help with this please consider a consultation with me. I’ve a good track record of helping people discover things they’ve never considered before. Or that their doctor missed.
Hi David,
Thank you for the response. How would I go about working with you? Fees, etc? Thanks!
Gary, details are on this page: https://nootropicsexpert.com/personal-consultations/. Go for the hour option to get started.
Hi David, I am going to reread the entire page on depression. Do you maybe have a suggestion on where to start? You have listed so many options.
My long term goal is to heal my depression. I agree that having some relief with the symptoms would be beautiful. After 5 years of being on antidepressants, anticovulsants and antipsychotics, I do have some amount of fear with playing with neurotransmitters.
Gary, I understand your fear. But using precursors to boost individual neurotransmitters is a helluva lot safer and gentler than using the meds your were using. The only thing is you need to try them one by one until you find that one that brings relief. That’s one option.
The other try boosting neurogenesis and see if healing brain cells will help. The easiest way to get started with that is trying something like Lion’s Mane Mushroom to increase nerve growth factor. And anything that boosts brain-derived neurotrophic factor (BDFN) may help as well: https://nootropicsexpert.com/13-nootropics-to-boost-bdnf/
So I would start with a two-pronged approach. Testing each neurotransmitter one at a time while using something to increase neurogenesis. And see how it goes. You’ll know within a week to 10-days if you’re on to something.
If that doesn’t work come back and we’ll try something else. Don’t despair because the last time I personally went through something similar it took me 2 1/2 years before I started feeling like a ‘normal’ health person again. Not saying that to scare you but put this into perspective. Now that you have help you may be able to shorten it to a month or two of experimenting or less.
Get started and report back on your progress please. We’re not going anywhere.
Hi David, I had an appointment scheduled with a holistic psychiatrist that I had to wait three weeks for. The appointment was last Wednesday. Her advice? She wants to prescribe lithium! So much for “holistic.” To be fair she would prescribe a low dose lithium carbonate – 150 mg. If that doesn’t work, up it to 300 mg. She said that a typical dose is 1200 mg. Quite frankly this plan scares the hell out of me!
So I will take your advice and purchase Lion’s Mane Mushroom to increase nerve growth factor asap, as you have suggested. Do you think I should just stick with that for a bit or also try a neurotransmitter simultaneously? If yes to the neurotransmitter, which one would you suggest I start with? In the past I have taken 5-HTP, L-Tryptophan, GABA (super briefly), ashwagandha and NAC.
Thank you so much for your advice!
Gary, if this psychiatrist prescribed Lithium she might be one to something. So instead of doing Lithium Carbonate like she suggests why not try Lithium Orotate? That is truly micro-dosing Lithium but it’s extremely effective. I use Advanced Research Lithium Orotate and it works great: https://amzn.to/3hwW8TW
If you want to try the neurotransmitter protocol you need to figure out which one is messed up in your brain. So which one of these supplements worked for you: 5-HTP, L-Tryptophan and GABA? If either of those worked and things improved it was either serotonin or GABA.
If it was neither of those then start with L-Tyrosine for dopamine or Alpha GPC for acetylcholine. Something is bound to work sooner or later.
Hi David, I responded last night but it seems to have disappeared. I wanted to wait until my appointment with a holistic psychiatrist before moving forward. Her recommendation is to take lithium carbonate! Not exactly holistic. She wants to prescribe 150 mg. She said if that did not bring me relief she would go up to 300 mg. She said it’s basic a micro dose.
I ordered the Lions Main Mushroom last night as you suggested. DO you think I should give this some time before possibly attempting to experiment with neurotransmitters?
I have tried a lot of the seratonin nnotropics – 5-HTP, SAM-e, L-Tryptophan, St. John’s Wart, etc. I have also tried GABA, NAC, ashwandha, and I’m sure others.
Where should I start? Thank you in advance.
Gary, it didn’t “disappear”. It’s me who is overwhelmed and just getting around to answering questions. Which I did below. Sorry for the delay.
Hi David, thank you for getting back to me. I have used lithium orotate years ago. I don’t remember it being helpful, but I am open to trying again. How much should I take per day?
The 5-HTP and others did nothing for me. I only took GABA for maybe a week for insomnia, so don’t know if it would help or not.
Do you think I should try L-Tyrosine for dopamine or Alpha GPC for acetylcholine together or try one at a time? Also, would you recommend the lithium by itself before trying either L-Tyrosine or Alpha GPC?
Thank you so much for your help.
Gary,
Lithium isn’t contraindicated with much so feel free to take it as needed. The usual dosage is 5 mg 3-times per day or “as needed”. But there are some who have come off of high dose lithium carbonate and the like and used double the ‘regular’ dose of Lithium Orotate with some success. So you’ll need to experiment.
If you are going to try the other neurotransmitters try then one-at-a-time. For example, L-Tyrosine for dopamine for a day or two. If that works then stay with it. If not, try Alpha GPC for acetylcholine for a day or two. Same protocol.
The key with success and nootropics is trial and error. And keep on trying until you find what works. Eventually, you’ll get there. It took me 2 1/2 years to finally feel like my healthy “self” again. But anyone reading this can do it much quicker with all the information available on Nootropics Expert.
Keep in mind that these neurotransmitters naturally decline with age. So using GABA for sleep may not be very noticeable. But your body and brain likely need it. Same with L-Tryptophan for serotonin. While it may not get rid of your depression completely, it may bring your levels up a couple levels. And that in concert with other things you’re using may come together so you’re feeling more like your healthy self again.
Hi David, thank you so much for the advice. I know how bust you are and so appreciate your help!
The lithium orotate that you recommended is not highly rated. I probably shouldn’t have read the 1 and 2 star reviews on Amazon. You still think this is the best option? I used this product way in the past but probably not 5 mg three times a day.
I texted with the holistic psychiatrist on her thoughts on trying orotate vs carbonate. She said we can talk about it on Wednesday. 🙂 I’ll wait to hear back from her.
My gut is to probably trying the L-Tyrosine and or Alpha GPC as you suggested. So you think trying one for only two days will be long enough to see if it is helpful? Do you have brands that you recommend for both?
I have been taking L-Tryptophan (along with magnesium L-Threonate) for two and a half weeks per the recommendation of the neurologist sleep doctor. I have been doing Restrictive Sleep Therapy for two and a half weeks. Unsuccessfully. He had me take Lunesta (2 mg) for a week last week to see if I could make it through 11:45 pm – 5:45 am. Unsuccessfully. So now he wants me to take 12.5 mg of Ambien extended release for only three nights – going to bed at 12:30 am and getting up at 5:45 am. His hope is that I’ll make it through the full 5 hours and 15 minutes.
He did say that if the insomnia is caused by major depression and not withdrawals from weaning off of Abilify, Lamictal and Zoloft – it will be much harder to cure the insomnia. If it is even possible. And that the therapy may be making it worse. Which I believe it is doing so.
This is why I am wanting to figure out how to get the depression under control. I just don’t know how much I will be able to tell if the supplements are effective since I am so tired! Ten and a half months of this shit.
I did start the Lion’s Mane per your suggestion three days ago.
Gary, I only recommended the Advanced Research Lithium Orotate because I’ve tried a couple of other brands. And the Advanced Research one is more effective. For me! That may not be true for everyone.
L-Tyrosine and Alpha GPC both work quickly to make dopamine and acetylcholine. But they require cofactors to accomplish this synthesis. Without going into detailed microbiology here, they will work for you if you are using a B-Complex, magnesium and Vitamin C. Or you could use a multi like the Performance Lab NutriGenesis Multi and cover all the necessary vitamin and mineral cofactors needed to make these neurotransmitters.
A couple of days each should be enough to get an idea if either of them provide any benefit. If one of them does work for you then long-term use following dosage recommendations for that supplement will improve with time. These are the two I am presently using: https://amzn.to/3hFMz51 and https://amzn.to/3lva96L
Hi David, I don’t know if this is something you can advise on or not. I tried Sleep Restriction Therapy for three weeks with no real success. When I was on Lamictal, Zoloft and Abilify, I slept 8-9 hours. I’m lucky to sleep 5 now (going on for 11 months). If I had to guess, it was the Abilify that put me to sleep. It looks like Abilify correlates to Dopamine. But I can’t quite figure out f it lowers or raises it. And if it raises it, would it make sense to try L-Tryptophan to see if it helps me sleep? My understand is that Tryptophan/Dopamine does the opposite. Thanks!
I may have typed out Tryptophan when I meant Tyrosine. Lack of sleep is killing me.
Gary, Abilify acts by modulating neurotransmission overactivity of dopamine. And it does it by acting on several different dopamine receptors as well as a couple serotonin receptors.
Note that ‘overactivity” is the keyword here. It certainly doesn’t raise dopamine. The last thing you’d want to do is take L-Tyrosine before bed.
Have you tried my sleep stack? It includes Tart Cherry juice from concentrate for melatonin, L-Tryptophan for serotonin and melatonin, and magnesium to relax muscles and it acts on the GABAa receptor. The same receptor that Ambien works on. See that stack here: https://nootropicsexpert.com/best-sleep-supplements-to-buy/ and here: https://nootropicsexpert.com/best-nootropics-for-sleep/.
If that’s not enough you could add CDB Oil, L-Theanine and Lemon Balm. That’s what I do and works like a charm.
Hi David, I will look into the Performance Lab sleep product. I have seen you recommend it on other threads.
The sleep doctor has me on Magnesium L-Theonate (he says it’s the best and or only one that crosses the blood brain barrier), 500 mg of L-Tryptophan and 5 mg of time release melatonin. I stopped with the melatonin after a few days. I find I react strangely to it.
I bought some Lemon Balm recently and added it to the above last night for the first time along with Sleepy Time Tea (which I have now taken three nights). My sleep was still terrible. About 5 hours. Last night I couldn’t fall asleep, which has not been my issue. I have also had migraines two of the last three days so I am cutting out the tea.
The Lab Performance is half the dose of Tryptophan that I am presently taking. You think the Taurate is more effective than Theonate? I had just started taking Magnesium Glycinate a few nights before I saw the sleep doctor. so many forms of magnesium!
Do you think it makes more sense to go to the Lab Performance rather than stick with Theonate, 500 mg of Tryptophan and purchasing Tart Cherry capsules? Thanks!
Gary, sounds like you witnessed the same bad reaction to melatonin I did.
The Performance Lab Sleep product is a good stack. But I find that some need to add to it. It works better the longer you use it.
Don’t forget that the sleep benefit of magnesium is more than in just your brain. You whole body goes to sleep and not just your brain. So the different forms of magnesium work together for body and brain.
BTW, I’ve come across studies since that shows magnesium glycinate and magnesium taurate cross the blood-brain barrier. I think when they invented the L-Threonate version of magnesium fewer options of magnesium where on the market.
You’ll need to keep experimenting Gary. I suggest trying CBD Oil too. Try the CBD Oil ‘Calm’ Gummies from Charlotte’s Web. Another thing that I find helps me stay asleep is Kratom. But specifically the Bentuangie strain of Kratom.
Try enegry therapy along with the herbs to release the trauma.
Hi C.C.
What type(s) of energy healing are you suggesting? Thanks.
Hi David!
Any Nootropic which can help me to get over loss of my family member? The memories and old euphoric feelings are eating me inside out.
Sarah, unfortunately there is no nootropic for grief. That’s not the way they work and not what they are for. Sure, nootropics can help alleviate the symptoms of depression. And it helps to know the cause of that depression so you know what to use. But grief and depression are not synonymous. Only a grief counsellor can help with what you must be going through Sarah. I’m so sorry for your loss.
Hi David, i left over a comment on one of your pages but i don’t think you’ve seen it.. i just really need answers for i feel lost, im suffering from srri & wellbutrin induced apathy/anhedonia, brain fog, memory issues from antidepressants such as prozac , zoloft and then wellbutrin & gabapentin. its been around 6 months since i last took wellbutrin. ive been taking, ginkgo,rhodiola,brahmi,gotu kola,DHA,NAC,l theanine, raw cacao, turmeric,Alcar, tulsi,& lithium orotate. i was thinking of trying something like Uridine, Noopept, Sulbutiamine, & Lions mane maybe, i feel like my dopamine receptors have been depleted from taking wellbutrin for 3 yrs. do you think any of those nootropics i’ve mentioned will help at all in repairing them? I’d really appreciate your help.. you help so many people and its admirable. i just am not sure where to go from here & what i should take. Thank you so much. Hope you’re having a wonderful night.
Gigi, see my response under the Sulbutiamine and Uridine threads.
Try heavy exercise..till you sweat hard,you will get adapted to it in 2-3 weeks, take whey protein along with it , I’m not an expert…But it does helped me to tackle drug induced motivational issues and made my life overall better..initial pain is hard but no pain,no gain.. these are all my opinions only, have a try along with nootropics
Hi David,
I’m strugling with depression and anxiety issues for quitte some time now, and at night i often have panic attacks which are really frightening.
My anxiety most of the time is much worse at night then during the day, because during the day i can control my mind to some degree.
For these symptoms i’m taking Escitalopram 15mg a day which helps somewhat against anxiety during the day, but panic atacks at night are still present unfortunately. Also it doesn’t help for depression so much in my experience.
Sometimes i don’t know what to do anymore. I tried a lot of stuff but the only things that seem to give me some instant relief are Magnesium, Taurin, Melatonin and a couple other supplements.
Things i did not really tried are racetams and noopept, and i am really curious to try some of them, espicially noopept. I have red a lot of good things about it! My brain often felt like a huge brainfog, i feel depressed, lack motivation to do any thing and everything i do i don’t really enjoy doing it!
I miss a feeling of a calm and clearheaded mind, i feel a lot of stress and my thougts are so racing i most of the time feel terrible and can’t focus on things.
From all i red online noopept can fix these issues, mostly people with mental ilnesses can benefit from it. And i am one of those people. My only question is if it can be combined with Escitalopram 15 mg? (SSRI)
Jacob, if you feel you’re getting some benefit from Escitalopram then you must be having at least some issues with serotonin. Low serotonin has been implicated in both anxiety and depression.
The thing is while you’re using that drug you can’t ‘directly’ boost serotonin with a nootropic. You must avoid using something like L-Tryptophan or St. John’s wort. Because if you do you’ll put yourself in danger of Serotonin Syndrome.
One nootropic that does compliment the use of Escitalopram is Inositol. Please see this review: https://nootropicsexpert.com/vitamin-b8-inositol/
Here’s a suggestion… Closely read the reviews here on Nootropics Expert for each of the supplements you’ve experienced some benefit. I think after reading a few of them you’ll come to recognize a pattern. Because some of them work on the same or similar brain function.
For example, taurine supports GABA as does magnesium. So you may have a problem with GABA as well. It may be wise to try boosting GABA in your brain. Try using GABA and L-Theanine before bed and see if that helps.
Noopept may be another good option because it also boosts Alpha Brain Waves just like L-Theanine. And it activates AMPA receptors which go on to activate the dopamine/motivation pathway as described in this post: https://nootropicsexpert.com/hacking-motivation-with-nootropics/
Another one to try is Lithium Orotate which may help reduce the panic attacks: https://nootropicsexpert.com/lithium-orotate/
You’re on the right track Jacob. I encourage you to continue experimenting with different nootropics. But do it wisely and carefully so you’re not messing with Escitalopram. And use the recommended dosages at the right time of day for the most benefit.
Thanks David! Are you saying Noopept could be combined with Escitalopram? That’s what i make out of your comment. 😉
I’m also interested in Lithium Orotate and Aniracetam for their stated mood lifting effects. Do you think it will be helpful for my situation I’m dealing with?
From my own research i know EPA and DHA, Curcumin, Lavender, Vitamin D3 and a good Probiotic supp can also help combat depression and anxiety. So that i plan to take on a regular basis combined with a good Multivitamin.
I think Colllagen (because it is made up from different amino acids) can also benefit the brain in a positive way. The Glycine in the collagen is also good for sleep like Magnesium is, so that in particular peeked my interest!
At last i want to mention PEA (palmitoylethanolamide) which i want to try for chronic pain. As it is anti inflammatory it could also help combat depression. I red an article that stated that people on this substance had far less depression symptoms then the placebo group. Unfortunately there was just one article about this, but still it is interesting!
What do you think about this? Am i on the right track? Do you have any good other supps i could try?
Thanks 🙂
Jacob, PEA does boost dopamine and serotonin which is why it helps some with depression symptoms. But it has an extremely short half-life and the effect doesn’t last long. So some like to prologue the effects of PEA by using it with a monoamine oxidase-B inhibitor (MAOI) like selegiline (L-deprenyl), hordenine, or Oat Straw. Any natural nootropic that acts like an MAOI should work.
Chronic pain is often caused by inflammation and can certainly contribute to feelings of depression. I suggest you do a search of Nootropics Expert (top right of the to menu) and search for the keywords “inflammation”, “COX-2”, “anti-inflammatory”, and “pain” and see what else turns up.
You are definitely on the right track sir! Just keep on doing your research. There’s likely hundreds of pages on this site you haven’t seen yet. There’s stuff I haven’t seen for years and I wrote everything on Nootropics Expert!
I hope you can help me further, you seem to know your stuff! 🙂
Hey, the only time I had night time panic attacks was when taking L-Tryptophan before going to bed. Maybe you should try leaving Melatonin out, while in Escitalopram. But I am just a random guy on the Internet.
Hi there, thank you for this brilliant resource. I have had depression for a long, long time and I have tried lots of things. I think that the main issue I have is long term low dopamine levels. Whether this is due to low levels of dopamine or the receptors not working efficiently, I don’t know. I would like to try some Mucuna for this and I know you mention that one should boost serotonin and dopamine together, but is there any merit in doing them separately first to see whether it is dopamine or serotonin or both that is the issue? If I start with Mucuna for a while and then maybe stop that and use Tryptophan, would that help me to separate the symptoms? Not sure if this is a valuable thing to do.
Antheia, the latter is what I suggest. Try one first then the other and see if you can figure out the cause of your depression. If neither help it could be something like inflammation that is the cause. But only thing that works is trial an error to get to the bottom of it.
Thank you for sharing, I am just learning about this topic and experimenting for optional mental health for myself. I have discontinued Zoloft and began taking a 5htp supplement. Overall very happy, but noticing fatigue. I tried a L Tyrosine supplement, which my body seemed to react both good ( at times, stretches of calm focus) but overall not well ( difficultly breathing, feelings of despair and anxiety.) this is the first time I am hearing 5 htp is not the way to go. Should i switch to tryptophan instead? Does taking tryptophan not require dopamine support?
Natalie, 5-HTP is not a great choice because it is difficult to get the dose correct. And clinical studies as well as user accounts report that consistent daily usage of 5-HTP backfires on people because it stops providing any benefit after a few weeks.
L-Tryptophan is a far safer choice for raising serotonin. And can be used daily for years if you follow dosage recommendations and learn what dose works best for you.
And you are correct that dopamine and serotonin must be in balance. Excess dopamine depresses serotonin and the reverse is true as well.
But if you are already low in serotonin you may not need L-Tyrosine to raise dopamine because your levels are already optimal.
Hi David,
What are advisable nootropics for higher serotonin levels?
I seem to feel worse after all medications that touch or increase dopamine so I would like to avoid such nootropics, but I need ones that work for serotonin, and maybe noradrenaline. Recently I started taking Rhadiola but only for 3 days. I was thinking about adding L-theanine but it seems to affect dopamine and serotonin mainly if I’am correct?
I also noticed bad reaction after taking NAC so I want to avoid similar nootropics to NAC.
Can I connect taking Ashwaganda with Rhadiola? Or better Rhadiola and L-theanine.
Best
Maciej, the simplest way to increase serotonin is using its precursor: L-Tryptophan (https://nootropicsexpert.com/tryptophan/)
I will get gloomy if I consume caffeine and do not exercise. It takes about 3 weeks for the gloom to appear. Once I stop the caffeine and start exercising I start to feel good in 2-3 weeks. As I am pushing 70 now my knees prevent me from being as active as I once was. Also I love how coffee let’s me focus but must avoid it for the reason above. Got any suggestions? Thanks
Tom, first you need to know what you are dealing with and this post will help with that: https://nootropicsexpert.com/best-nootropics-for-the-aging-brain/
If you used the suggestions in that post it may take 1 – 3 weeks of consistent use. But it wouldn’t be long before you no longer feel gloomy.
Hi David. What do you think about the following as a daily stack for depression, mood, and focus : ALCAR, NALT, Alpha GPC, Aniracetam, Uridine, Sulbutiamin, Phosphotadylserine, Theanine, Fish Oil, and Multivitamin ? Thank you.
Noel, should definitely improve focus. But for mood aka depression you’ll need to try it and see what happens.
As detailed in this post depression has any number of causes. If this stack nails it then you’re good. But if there’s still some depression hanging around you’ll need to revisit the elements of this stack you are using for depression. Let me know if you need any help.
Hi David. Is it safe and effective to take L-Tryptophan every night before bedtime to facilitate sleep and serotonin? Thank you.
Noel, taking L-Tryptophan before bedtime is the safest way to boost serotonin and facilitate sleep. And it very effective. I’ve been using it for the last couple of years as part of my “sleep stack”. And it works.
Hi David. If I am taking L-Tryptophan every night before bedtime, do I need to be taking NALT every morning in a corresponding move to avoid an imbalance in dopamine and serotonin? Thank you.
Noel, maybe and maybe not. It depends on things like your unique brain chemistry, lifestyle, living environment, etc.
I suggest learning to recognize the side effects of excess serotonin. And if you experience any of them then consider adding NALT.
Of course there is no harm in doing both right now as long as you’re following dosage recommendations. And if these nootropics agree with you.
Hi David. Is it safe and effective to take Alpha GPC 150mg every day without a racetam? I know that a lot of people take a choline source such as Alpha GPC primarily to avoid a headache while taking a racetam, but is Alpha GPC on its own right an effective supplement for mood and focus? Thank you.
Noel, it sure is a great nootropic on its own. You can read the full review here: https://nootropicsexpert.com/alpha-gpc/. Then scroll down to the section: “How does Alpha GPC feel?”.
Alpha GPC suggested dosage for cognitive benefits is 400 – 1,200 mg per day. With higher dosages split into 2 or 3 smaller doses during the day.
Hi David. I believe ALCAR, NALT, and Alpha GPC are all water-soluble and should be taken with water on empty stomach before breakfast. Is it safe and effective to take all 3 together as part of a daily stack before breakfast? Thank you.
Noel, I imagine there may be some competition for transporters between them but I find they work just as well when taken together.
Hi David. Just wanted to share with you a daily stack that I have been using recently with much success as far as focus and general well-being. Before breakfast on empty stomach, I am taking ALCAR (1 gram), NALT (400 mg), Alpha GPC (300 mg), and Theanine (200 mg). Then after breakfast, I am taking Vitamin D (5000 iu), Fish Oil (1 gram combined EPA/DHA), multivitamin, and 2 cups of coffee. Finally, before bedtime, I am taking L-Tryptophan (500 mg). Tell me what looks good here and please suggest anything that you think might help. Thank you.
Noel, if this stack is working well for you then it sounds like you have issues with dopamine and acetylcholine. So look for other nootropics that help support those neurotransmitters and their receptors.
Hi David. Last night, to facilitate sleep before bedtime, I took 500 mg of L-Tryphtophan and 3mg of sublingual melatonin. Is that safe? I actually slept incredibly well, but want to make sure that its safe to take both at the same time and avoid the dreaded “serotonin syndrome” that I’ve heard about. Thank you.
Noel, it’s not Serotonin Syndrome you need to worry about with that combo. But rather how you feel.
I recommend avoiding melatonin because you don’t really know how much melatonin you’re using. Studies have shown that the amount of melatonin listed on the bottle almost always is NOT what’s in the capsule. It’s either dramatically less or much more that what’s listed. Quality control seems to be non existent with this supplement.
My personal experience is I had to stop using even 1/2 mg because my wife noticed a change in personality the next day. And it wasn’t nice. So if you decide to try it for a few nights, pay close attention to how you feel the next day.
It’s much safer to get your melatonin by using about 6 oz. of Tart Cherry Juice from concentrate (not a juice blend) which is a natural source of this nootropic.
Hi David. What do you think about taking L-Tryphtophan and Tart Cherry Concentrate in capsule form on a nightly basis to facilitate sleep? Is this combination both safe and effective ? Thank you.
Noel, yes it’s effective and what is in Performance Lab Sleep: https://nootropicsexpert.com/performance-lab-sleep-review/. You’ll get the best results from that supplement the longer you use it. With full benefits after about 3 weeks of daily use.
Hi David. If these nootropics are working well, which I believe they are, is there really any reason at all to take any race tams? Do you believe that race tams are essential to any nootropic stack, or just a complement to enhance the stack? Thank you.
Noel, if you’ve found a stack that works for you then do NOT change it. Not until you need to. I cannot stress how important this. Because it took so much work to get this point as any experienced neurohacker would admit.
The racetams are an option. But they are NOT necessary to make a successful nootropic stack.
Hi David. Are you a fan of all the Performance Labs products ? I am curious about the mens multivitamin, energy, and sleep products specifically, but wonder what you thought about the company and their products in general too. Thank you.
Noel, the Performance Lab Wholefood Multi is the best multivitamin for men I’ve ever used. I use their Multi, Energy and Sleep products daily because I after researching the market and trying different things, these are by far the best and purest supplements on the market. They work and the price is right. Especially at this very moment when some of them are still on sale.
Hi David. What are your thoughts on Modafinil? Have you tried it? Please tell me what you think about it. Some people really swear by this one. Thank you.
Noel, I have no problem with Modafinil. Except that it is a prescription drug and NOT a nootropic.
I do not review drugs or “smart drugs” on Nootropics Expert. Only natural nootropics that anyone can buy without a prescription in most places in the world.
Hi David. I have been taking L-Tryptophan 500 mg every night to facilitate sleep. It does help but I still wake up quite often during the night. Can you recommend anything else to add as part of a “sleep stack” ? Thank you
Noel, you’re only getting one part of the sleep stack I’ve been using and writing about for the last few years. You can use these supplements individually like you have been doing or get them in two capsules here: https://nootropicsexpert.com/performance-lab-sleep-review/
Ok so in therapy they speak of Antidepressants to Help boost the brain to not be so reactive in bad moments.
I keep having bad cycles of depression and I do know why. But I’m so far down it’s hard to maintain positive when the going gets tough. (Applying therapy techniques, or following bible principles).
So I’ve been doing the Tyrosine, Taurine, C3+, B complex, NAC, CBD, CoCoa, Mg Theronate, 1/2 a Multi. I do it all with my fatty blueberry shake with collegian protein powered.
Anyway – no change. It’s been a month.
My attitude and fears work on me hard and it hurts and I lose hope. I get annoyed.
Anything help boost mood like a mood stabilizer?
Robert, please go back and start this post again from the top. Because it will help you understand that the only way to get to the bottom or the cause of your depression is through the process of elimination.
You’ve already found out that dopamine (i.e. Tyrosine) is not likely your problem. So now I suggest you try L-Tryptophan for serotonin and see if that helps. If it doesn’t then try Alpha GPC or CDP-Choline for acetylcholine and see if that helps. And so on through the rest.
If after investigating each of the neurotransmitters one by one doesn’t help then look at neurogenesis or inflammation next. I realize this may sound like a long, drawn out process while you’re still in agony. But it’s the only real way to get to the root of the problem.
But please note that things like Taurine, B-complex, NAC, Magneiusm L-Threonate, and a Multivitamin are all needed in any event. Whatever else you need to do you’ll still need these basics.
Hi David. I am new to nootropics and feel a bit overwhelmed with all the information and options for each condition. I found nootropics when looking for a way to manage my depression, anxiety and panic attacks. I have tired microdoscing psilocybin with good success but they can be hard to find and I need a consistent approach.
Reading the list of 25 nootropics for depression I just don’t know where to start. I know that I will have to experiment to find what works best for me, but can you suggest a good starting place? Before learning the term nootropics I tried Gaba and Dopa Mucuna with some relief, but the Dopa Mucuna leaves me over amped sometimes, and the Gaba feels like it helps but could be better. I am 53, just entered menopause, am obese & have insulin resistance, with a just recognized constant foundation of depression that can dip much lower when I’m triggered.
I thank you for any direction you can offer.
Rhonda, for insulin resistance try Berberine: https://nootropicsexpert.com/berberine/.
And it sounds like you’ve already had some success in finding the cause of at least some of your symptoms. Mucuna Pruriens provides L-DOPA which is a direct precursor to the synthesis of dopamine. So if it provided some benefit but was too strong for you, at least you know you could be dopamine deficient. So instead of Mucuna you should consider a step back in the dopamine pathway and try L-Tyrosine.
And if GABA provided some relief you could try increasing your dose. You didn’t mention your dosage of either of these supplements. But if it was 500 mg GABA before bed then try 750 mg the next time. And see how you feel the next day.
Thank you for your quick response David!
I’m started with 750mg GABA before bed and when that wasn’t quite doing it I also added another 750mg cap mid morning. I do feel better with the second dose but it’s hmmm, kinda like an itch that you can’t quite reach. I feel my mood is elevated but still just under the surface of feeling good. I read somewhere that GABA supplements don’t cross the blood brain barrier so I wonder if I’m just spinning my wheels on this one.
The Mucuna I was taking is 800mg. I’ll give the L-Tyrosine a try and see if I feel less amped.
Thank you for the recommendation of Berberine – I’ll check into that.
Do you think it would make sense to add anything like Aniracetam or Bacopa?
Again, thank you so much for your guidance!!
Rhonda, it’s true that the GABA molecule is too big to cross the blood-brain barrier. However, we think there may be a dedicated transporter for GABA to help it across. Or it may be that the magic happens in your gut which then communicates with your brain via your vagus nerve. Either way it seems that GABA supplements work for many people.
The other calming neurotransmitter is serotonin. So you could also try 500 mg L-Tryptophan before bed.
Aniracetam is a great antidepressant but needs to be dosed correctly including using it with a good choline supplement.
Thank you David. I’ll give your recommendations a try and see how they do before considering adding more. And thanks for the GABA explanation. Much appreciated!
David,
Thanks for the wonderful resources. Given that this product “Puritan’s Pride Soy Protein Isolate Powder” contains most of the amino acids of these list and others. Is it okay to use Puritan’s Pride Soy Protein Isolate Powder as a source of these nootropics?
Thanks,
Son
It sounds like you missed the entire message of this post. Depression can be caused by a number of things including problems with neurogenesis, neurotransmitter deficiencies, stress and more.
If you think the amino acids in Puritan’s Pride product are the correct dosages and address exactly the cause of your depression then it may work.
Thanks for your response David.
The product contains L-Tyrosine, L-Cysteine, L-Phenylalanine, L-Tryptophan. These are in this post. However it also contains L-Glutamic Acid, L-Arginine etc. My question is will the presence of these non essential amino acid interfere with or have adverse effect on depression?
Thank you,
Son
Son, these amino acids should have a positive effect on decreasing depression. But only if the dosages are high enough.
Given the short amount of time I have known your youtube channel and then your website. The resources you have gathered has been so help to me and other people I know.
Thank you so much Dave.
Son.
Hi Dave,
I was hoping to see some information on dl phenylalanine. I realize you can’t list everything and maybe it’s not considered a nootropic. From all the research I have done I decided to take it. I call it me head meds.
I take dL, glutamine and a high potency liquid b complex. I must admit when I sometimes go off of everything I can tell a big difference. I take the B-Complex because, well JSU because everyone should. The glutamine because if all the reports about the brain gut connection and how our health begins in the gut and the dL for anxiety and mood. I am supposed to be taking magnesium as well but for now I am working on trying to make sure I at least take the three listed above. I sometimes get busy and forget. I have read from multiple sources that amino acids will cancel each other out and not to take at the same time. So I take dL first think in the morning because you should eat any proteins for at least and hour and if I eat then I have to wait 2 hrs before I can take. Them later I take the glutamine and b complex at the same time. I will start adding the magnesium with this as well unless since two are a powder and one is a linguist I just mix it all in 4oz of juice and am done with it.
I’d love to know your thoughts on dL and if I am correct that I shouldn’t take aminos at the same time.
Thank you in advance
Misha
Misha, this is my review on L-Phenylalanine: https://nootropicsexpert.com/phenylalanine/. It’s a precursor to the synthesis of L-Tyrosine which goes on to make dopamine. Some find better results boosting dopamine when using L-Tyrosine.
Dosage recommendations say to not take amino acid supplements with food. The reason is because the amino acids in your food compete for the same amino acid transporters in your gut. So may not get the full benefit of the amino acid supplement. And why it’s suggested to use them an hour before or two hours after a meal.
Hi,
Seen a GP for pretty major depression. He wants me to go on Sertaline (Zoloft).
I’ve just started taking l-tyrosine and acetyl carnitine plus have ordered Mucuna (will alternate with tyrosine), aniracetam, sulbutiamine and alpha gpc from reading this site.
Wondering if there would be contraindications between this stack and the antidepressant?
Thanks!
Damien, Sertraline is a selective serotonin reuptake inhibitor (SSRI). So you definitely need to stay away from anything that directly boosts serotonin.
The supplements in your stack are primarily for dopamine. So you shouldn’t have a problem. But I’d double-check if I were you with the drug interaction checker to be sure: https://www.drugs.com/drug_interactions.html
Hi. I’m slowly lowering my cymbalta dosage. What nootropics are safe to take while doing this? I’m experiencing anxiety and major mood swings. Irritated.
Kristen, cymbalta inhibits the reuptake of serotonin and norepinephrine (NE) in the central nervous system. And increases dopamine (DA) specifically in the prefrontal cortex. So you want to completely avoid anything that directly increases dopamine or serotonin.
Lithium Orotate: https://nootropicsexpert.com/lithium-orotate/ is great for mood swings. But please check with your doctor before using it to make sure there are no contraindications.
Hi David. What are your thoughts on adding noopept and/or sulbutiamin with race tams ? Can they be taken every day with race tams as part of a stack, or better off cycled with race tams ?
Also, does Alpha GPC have to be used with noopept and/or sulbutiamin independent of race tams ? I know that Alpha GPC must be used with all race tams, but wonder if it needs to be used with others, like noopept and sulbutiamin.
Thank you.
Noel, Noopept needs to be used with Alpha GPC even though it’s not a true racetam.
Sulbutiamine is just two thiamine molecules bonded together so acts like any other Vitamin B1 (thiamine) supplement. Although it’s more effective.
I use Aniracetam every day and do not cycle. But some people find they need to cycle. Only you can know what works best for you.
Hi David. What are your thoughts on black seed oil ? I heard it was good for mood. Thank you.
Noel, I have’t done the research yet on Black Seed Oil but it looks promising. Apparently it boosts executive function in humans likely because it is an acetylcholinesterase inhibitor. Which increases acetylcholine in your brain. https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC4789020/
Hi David. Just recently took Fasoracetam, and I really like it, reminds me a lot of Aniracetam, in terms of mood and focus. Whats your thoughts on stacking 3 different racetams : Aniracetam, Fasoracetam, and Coloracetam? Is there a “limit” to how many racetams can safely and effectively be stacked together in one dose? Thank you.
Noel, there are no studies on stacking 2 or more racetams and I’m not aware of anyone using more than two different racetams at a time. The only thing I can suggest is comparing the mechanism of action of each racetam to make sure you’re not using two racetams that do basically the same thing in your brain.
Hi David. Are you a fan of stacking race tams ? For example, piracetam with aniracetam ? Thank you.
Noel, you need to compare the mechanism of action for each of the racetams you are considering to see if it makes sense to use both at the same time.
Hi David. Have you tried the newer race tams Fasoracetam and Coluracetam ? If so, what are your thoughts on them ? Thank you.
Noel, I’ve not tried either one. I did a full review on Coluracetam (https://nootropicsexpert.com/coluracetam/) but not for Fasoracetam.
Hi David. The coluracetam looks interesting and I think that I will try it soon. I agree with you on aniracetam being my favorite race tam. I do like how aniracetam stacks with noopept and of course Alpha GPC. BTW, do you plan on reviewing fasoracetam ? I would enjoy that greatly. Thank you.
Noel, Fasoracetam is not on my priority list because of its limited usefulness as a nootropic. But I’ll review it eventually.
Hi David. Whats your opinion on Semax and Tianpeptide ? Thank you.
Noel, both are used a prescription drugs in Russia I believe. So I’d consider “smart drugs” and not nootropics. I haven’t researched either one so can’t provide an opinion.
Hi David. I know that it is recommended to take a choline source such as Alpha GPC with race tams such as Piracetam and Anipiracetam. Now, is that primarily just to avoid heachaches or because the race tams simply won’t be effective without the added choline ? Some people just won’t get headaches, even without the choline source. But does that automatically mean that the race tams also won’t work properly like they should ? Thank you.
Noel, most racetams simply will not work as well if you don’t provide a supplemental choline source. And we can’t get enough choline from food.
Aniracetam for example boosts acetylcholine use in the brain by 200 – 300%. That extra acetylcholine needs to come from somewhere. And the only logical, simple way to do that is with something like Alpha GPC or CDP-Choline.
Hi David. Can noopept be taken together with race tams such as piracetam or aniracetam, along with Alpha GPC, or should noopept be cycled on days that race tams are cycled off ? Just wonder about the synergy factor.
Also, I know that you’re not a big fan of phenylpiracetam. But what about oxiracetam ?
Thank you.
Noel, when I use Noopept I use it the same days as I use Aniracetam. I’ve not personally tried Oxiracetam.
Hi David. I like to take Alpha GPC with race tams and noopept. However, am I better off with the 150mg from nootropics depot or the 300 mg from double wood? Is 150mg a sufficient daily source of choline if I am taking either noopept, piracetam , or aniracetam ?
Noel, you’re likely to need 300 – 600 mg per dose of whatever racetam you are using. You’ll know you’re not taking enough if you get a racetam-headache. But dosage unique to your brain will take some experimenting.
Hi David. Whats your opinion on noopept ? I am thinking about trying it. I heard its something that can be taken every day, with less cycling than racetams in general. Thank you.
Noel, I love Noopept and find that when I use it I’m more productive. Just make sure you dose it properly including with a choline supplement.
Hi David. I know that Alpha GPC and CDP Citicholine are generally recommended as choline sources to go with race tams and noopept to avoid headaches, but I’m wondering if ALCAR by itself is a sufficient source of choline to ward off headaches ? Thank you.
Noel, ALCAR is not sufficient when using racetams or Noopept. ALCAR contributes to the synthesis of acetylcholine but you still need a choline source like Alpha GPC or CDP-Choline.
Hi David. What do you think about Magnesium Threonate ? I hear it crosses the BBB easily. How does it compare to Magnesium Glycinate ? Can it be taken in the morning for energy and mood, or just evening before bedtime ? Thank you!
Noel, both are good choices. I personally use Magnesium Glycinate 400 mg before bed. But lately I’ve been dosing 400 mg in the morning and another 400 mg at noon. It doesn’t help in the energy dept. but it does help keep my blood pressure down and never needing to worry about constipation.
Hi David. Is it true that ALCAR is one of the best to take every day, because of its positive effects in so many areas ? I take 1 gram powder form in water before breakfast every day. Does ALCAR provide good synergy taken with NALT, Rhodiola, Sulbutiamin, Aniracetam, and Alpha GPC ? I still don’t think that I would take all of them the same day every day, because of the concern of building tolerance, especially with the NALT, Sulbutiamin, and Aniracetam. So for example, Monday its ALCAR with NALT with Rhodiola. Tuesday its ALCAR with Sulbutiamin. Wednesday its ALCAR with Aniracetam and Alpha GPC. How does that sound to you ? Thanks!
Noel, do whatever works for you. I take them every day. But some prefer to cycle things like Aniracetam and Sulbutiamine. But ALCAR is something that your body naturally uses every day no matter whether you get it from food or a supplement.
Hi David. I like the aniracetam. Gives me nice focus and mood boost. Of course, I do combine it with Alpha GPC to avoid a headache. I am intrigued with trying phenylpiracetam. I heard it gives a nice mental and physical boost too. Is this true ? Have you tried phenylpiracetam ? How do you rank it next to aniracetam ? Thank you.
Noel. I’ve tried Phenylpiracetam and do not like the way it made me feel. All you can do is try it and see if you like it. In very broad terms one is an anxiolytic and the other a stimulant.
Hi David,
I was under medicated for hypothyroidism in Sept and my body took 3 months to show symptoms. Unfortunately by that time a cascade of problems had already been set in motion. It started with a massive stress response and an inability to relax. Then gut issues. In April when I was really struggling I decided to swap thyroid medications in the hope that it would recover my mood and restore T3 levels… bad mistake. It sent me into a deep depression. Before this ideal I had never experienced depression. It is debilitating. So I went back to my original medication and the deepness lifted somewhat. But I am still having a massive stress response and depression. I have cleaned up my diet and have recovered my gut health somewhat.. am walking lots to mitigate the stress response and doing yoga. I am taking a bunch of supplements but the only ones I’ve noticed make a difference are valerian and holy basil. I’ve read that might be due to adrenal fatigue and cortisol? Or GABA imbalance? I know it’s a long shot but any insight or suggestions you might have would be great.
Thanks
🙂
Tara, if you click on the “About” tab in the menu you’ll find I went through something very similar to you. And it took nearly 3 years of experimenting and healing before I felt great again.
I suggest you get a copy of Janie Bowthorpe’s book “Stop the Thyroid Madness” (https://amzn.to/2xglRKL) where you’ll get the best advice for digging out of the hole you’re in. And come back to Nootropics Expert to research some of the supplements recommended in that book.
Hello David. I understand that you take Aniracetam and Sulbutiamin every day, but I am concerned about building tolerance if I take them every day. My question is that if I cycle them, what is the best “method” for cycling ? In other words, take both together for 5 consecutive days then 2 days off, or take Aniracetam on Monday, Sulbutiamin on Tuesday, Aniracetam on Wednesday, Sulbutiamin on Thursday, etc. ? BTW, why do you think it is that you are able to take them both every day without losing effectiveness ? Many people report building tolerance of Sulbutiamin especially, and I’m afraid that I will fall into that category for some reason. Thank you.
Noel, if you are concerned about tolerance then take each of them every second day. I don’t worry about ‘tolerance’ because I’m not seeking any particular noticeable feeling like euphoria. I just want to feel good all the time. But euphoria is not sustainable long-term.
Hello David. I was wondering if you could clarify which of the following nootropics are water soluble and which are fat soluble ? I have been taking ALCAR and NALT with water only before breakfast on empty stomach. Then with breakfast, I take a combination of sulbutiamin, aniracetam, alpha GPC, uridine, rhodiola, phosphatidylserine, theanine, vitamin d, fish oil, and multivitamin. Am I doing this right, or do I need to change what I take with water and what I take with food ? Thank you.
Noel, each individual review includes whether it is fat- or water-soluble. Your dosing schedule is correct.
Hi David. I was wondering what you think of BANG energy drink for a nice mood lift and energy ? Do you recommend any specific energy drinks ? Thank you.
Noel, the BANG energy drinks are not to bad but some may find issues with the caffeine in it. Same with 5-hour Energy. That was likely the first “nootropic drink” and no one noticed. I certainly discounted it and never looked into it until today. Shame on me for my prejudices.
Hello David. Recently found your website and absolutely love it. I am new to nootropics, but learning so much from it to better myself. I am taking ALCAR every day in the morning with a cup of water before breakfast on an empty stomach. I take ALCAR with NALT every other day (3-4 days a week) to avoid building up Tyrosine tolerance (I heard that the brain will shut off Tyrosine if taken every day). Then, with breakfast, I will take Alpha GPC with Uridine, and Vitamin D 500, fish oil, multivitamin, and Phosphatidylserine. But I don’t take the Alpha GPC with Uridine every day. I will cycle it every other day with either Rhodiola (3% rosavins to 1% salidroside) or Sulbutiamin. I am thinking about adding Aniracetam to my cycled stack (adding Alpha GPC with it as a choline source). Am I on the right track here ? Please tell me the best way to cycle my favorite nootropics to keep long term effectiveness and avoid tolerance. Thank you so much!
Noel, you are definitely on the right track. As for tolerance, it all depends on how your brain works and what works for you. I use NALT or L-Tyrosine 3-times per day and don’t have a problem with tolerance. Because my brain is starved of dopamine.
The key is finding what works for you and listening to your body. It will tell you when you are doing the right thing to support it.
David, which ones that I mentioned above can safely and effectively be taken every single day, and which ones need to be cycled ? Thanks so much.
Noel, there is nothing that needs to be cycled in my opinion. It entirely depends on dosages and how your individual brain works. I personally do not cycle anything because I only use what my brain demands. You may find differently. Only way to know is experimenting.
Hi David. I have been taking ALCAR daily and it seems to give me good background focus every day. But I am really intrigued by Aniracetam and Sulbutiamin. Should I be taking both together every day, or maybe better off taking just the Aniracetam on Monday, then Sulbutiamin on Tuesday, back to Aniracetam on Wednesday, and then Sulbutiamin on Thursday, etc. ? Thank you.
Noel, I use the daily and have for years. Just make sure you add CDP-Choline or Alpha GPC if you’re going to use Aniracetam.
David, you ARE the best! Thank you for all your help, nobody else explains everything so well, and completely as you. Thank-you-thank-you. I have fought depression all my life, shock treatments, hospitalized, with really not a lot of help until I found you. Bless you so much. Audrey
Is it safe to sulbutiamine,if you’re on Effexor antidepressant 2 daily 75mg
Kenneth, should not be a problem depending on what you are using Effexor for. Please see the “side effects” section above.
I have been on Lexapro for 17 years. I went off it cold turkey last year and stayed off for about a year. After watching your videos on Youtube, I see that with proper experimentation, it could be possible for me to wean myself off the SSRI being careful not to take anything that could cause Serotonin Syndrome, then after I am off for a certain amount of time, introduce some nootropics that positively affect Serotonin. From what I’ve read it appears that St John’s Wort, L-Tryptophan, 5HTP, and possibly Rhodiola Rosea would have adverse reactions while tapering off SSRI’s. Nootropics that I think would be safe while tapering are Ginkgo Biloba, Lion’s Mane Mushroom and possibly Bacopa Monnieri. I have used Dr Daniel Amen’s brand called Brain and Memory Booster which contains several amino acids including NAC in addition to Vinpocetine and Huperzine. I didn’t see any ill effects while taking it along with Lexapro.
My question is, can you recommend the best nootropics to utilize over a period of a few months that won’t have any adverse reactions with the drug while tapering off ? Thank you in advance. You are a great resource in this field. Keep up the good work.
Dan, the best thing to do is avoid anything that is contraindicated with Lexapro. Which is a potent serotonin reuptake inhibitor. So stay away from any nootropic that directly boosts serotonin. For example, L-Tryptophan or 5-HTP. And anything that is a strong modulator of serotonin or its receptors or synapses. Noopept for example seems to stimulate dopamine, nicotinic AND serotonin receptors. That’s the kind of thing to watch out for.
Thanks David. I’ll be sure to stay away from any of the serotonin stimulators while still on lexapro. I assume Aniracetam would be a no go as well, Correct ?
Dan, you should be OK with Aniracetam because it does not affect serotonin. It acts on acetylcholine, and AMPA receptors which are associated with glutamate and GABA. Just make sure you use it with a choline supplement like Alpha GPC or CDP-Choline.
Hi Jonathan, I was just wondering if you tried the Lion’s mane with Zoloft? I am also thinking about it but concerned about the interaction
Hi David,
I would very much appreciate your help.
Even though I consider myself as a decent person, I have been stupid enough to have an abuse of amphetamine for about a year. The last six month, I have ended up using about 100-150 mg every day because of the consequence of withdrawal symptoms, which manifests in the form of depression, fatigue, brain fog and lack of motivation.
Despite of my amphetamine abuse, I ironically enough live a very healthy life consuming daily many different fruits and vegetables, nuts, vitamins, a low intake of unhealthy fats, and sugar is almost non existent in my life. I have worked out in the gym 3-4 times a week for the last 20 years. Therefore I’m pretty sure, that my symptoms are the result of the daily tampering of the serotonin levels and dopamine depletion in my brain.
I have now decided that this must come to an end now, and I would prefer doing this without prescription drugs and still be able to keep my fulltime job.
So I started a couple of weeks ago to read about the possibilities of nootropics, so I am very inexperienced in this vast universe. From what I have read by now, I have an assumption that I could benefit of a nootropic stack consisting of:
L-tryptophan, vitamin B3, B6, and cherry tart juice for the rebalancering of my serotonin levels and sleep quality. Or maybe 5-HTP if L-tryptophan isn’t effective enough for this matter…??? I am aware of the danger of serotonin syndrome, so if 5-HTP is to be used, I will of course have to stay totally away from the amphetamine from that moment on.
N-Acetyl-Tyrosine/L-Phenylalanine, for rebalancering my dopamine levels. Or maybe L-dopa will be a better choice…???
Aniracetam for dealing with the anxiety, fatigue – and depression (which the above mentioned also will be useful for. Could Kava Kava maybe also be useful for dealing with anxiety..?
And then there of course is SAM-e, St. John’s wort and many others, but I really need some guidance for choosing a stack AND dosage as a good starting point, and then I can adjust from there if needed.
It will probably not be a good idea to quit the amphetamine cold turkey, so I am planning on tapering off from it gradually. Would you agree on this..?
Hope to hear from you.
Best Regards
John
John, sounds like you’ve done your homework on what needs to be done here. And your nootropic stack suggestion is certainly on the right track.
You many want to consider trying https://nootropicsexpert.com/phenylethylamine/ which is a TAAR1 agonist and could help with withdrawal symptoms. Quitting ‘cold turkey’ is not a good idea and could be dangerous.
Here’s a tip … this Wikipedia entry is the best explanation on how amphetamines work I’ve come across: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Amphetamine. Study this thing because it will likely spark some ideas on what else you can do. Supplemental magnesium is one suggestion I found in this post.
Anything you can find that increases the density of dopamine receptors will help. I know there are 1 or 2 reviewed here but can’t think of them at the moment. Do a search top right to find them.
Follow the dosage instructions carefully for each of the nootropics you mentioned in your comment. Experimenting is key to finding what works best for you. And do not be shy about finding a local chapter of Narcotics Anonymous if you need to. The right group could be one of the best things you could do while you are on the road to recovery.
Study I’m referring to re: number 2 here:
https://developingchild.harvard.edu/wp-content/uploads/2005/05/Stress_Disrupts_Architecture_Developing_Brain-1.pdf
“Sustained activation of the stress response system
can lead to impairments in learning, memory,
and the ability to regulate certain stress
responses. In both young and adult animals,
high, sustained levels of cortisol or corticotropin-releasing
hormone (CRH), which is the brain chemical that regulates the HPA system,
result in damage to a part of the brain called the
hippocampus. This area of the brain is critical
to both learning and memory as well as to some
types of stress response regulation.
Hi,
I can’t find the studies you cited, when I click them it just reopens the same page.
Also, I have 2 fundamental questions:
1. In your opinion, is there currently any nootropic on the market that actually raises IQ (however minor)?
2. Depression is sometimes described as brain damage due to chronically elevated Cortisol levels. In your opinion are there nootropics capable of repairing said (theoretical) damage?
Mike, for the studies you click on the Roman numeral next to the end of the sentence describing the study. And that click should take you down the the REFERENCES section under the review or page. Each clinical study has (source) which is a live link to the study. I just checked the ‘click’ and it seems to be working. If it isn’t for you then try updating your browser or try a different browser.
I know that L-Tyrosine has been shown to affect IQ. And there are others that I can’t think of off the top. The search function for the keyword “IQ” doesn’t seem to be working very well. I’ll have my developer look into it.
Elevated cortisol levels are associated with stress and inflammation. Several nootropics specifically address inflammation. And as I recall, a couple of them help lower cortisol levels. Bacopa Monnieri is one of them. A search for “cortisol” does work so check the search function please.
Hi David,
thanks for the very quick reply. After trying to click the source once more it finally worked. I like to check the studies myself, as sometimes the methodology isn’t great (small sample size, no control group etc.).
I wasn’t referring to Cortisol by itself, rather to the consequence of chronically elevated levels. Nevertheless, I’ll try and see what the search function brings to light.
Thanks for your reply.
Mike, check out this post for ideas > https://nootropicsexpert.com/best-nootropics-for-social-anxiety/
And this one > https://nootropicsexpert.com/top-7-nootropic-adaptogens-to-conquer-anxiety-and-stress/
Seems Ashwagandha, Gotu Kola and Lion’s Mane fit the bill. I’m already taking Bacopa, Uridine MP, Alpha GPC, Huperzine A and Ginkgo.
I’ve ordered Ashwagandha, will see how that will do. I ordered the most potent – KSM-66.
What do you reckon has the most lasting / permanent effects in terms of neurogenisis and neuronal repair? Is there a point where you reckon one can “stop” taking nootropics? After all, it is a bit pricey to keep restocking and consuming all these drugs.
On a different topic, I’ve also ordered mugwort tea. Have you ever tried it? I’ve tried Gelantamine for lucid dreaming, but it didn’t work. I’m hoping mugwort tea might work. Obviously flying and things like that are fun things to do, but I’m mainly interested in lucid dreaming as people have reported that it may help in resolving psychological issues. I’m also interested in learning during a lucid dream. But so far I’ve had zero success. Your input would be greatly appreciated.
Mike, I’ve had the most lucid dreams when using Methylene Blue. Sorry, but do not have any experience with mugwort tea.
The nootropic stack you are using which includes Lion’s Mane will have the most lasting and permanent effects on neurogenesis and brain repair. I hear you loud and clear on cost. But my experience has been I cannot afford to stop using the ALL of the stack that I am using now.
I’ve become so in-tune with how this brain and body work that if I run out of something and don’t use it for a week I can feel it. And I don’t like it.
The thing about nootropics is you can always stop using them. And for most with no withdrawal or side effects. But boy does it suck going back to feeling like you used to.
have you seen Lions mane mushroom interact with zoloft….or i guess any anti depressants?
Jonathan, I haven’t come across any reported interactions with Lion’s Mane and anything including prescription antidepressants. Not to say there aren’t any. Just haven’t seen any.
Hi David,
I guess finding the right Nootropic for depression depends on the cause of the depression. I’ve tried many anti depressants, most did not work with the expextion of Effexor which as you know Is an SNRI.
Which Nootropics would you say have a similar function in the brain as an SNRI?
Thanks for all your help!
Michael, this is the mechanism of action for Effexor: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Venlafaxine#Mechanism_of_action
So it appears that it boosts levels of serotonin AND norepinephrine in the brain. At higher dosages it also appears to boost dopamine to some extent.
The goal here is to find nootropic that boost serotonin and norepinephrine (NE). Serotonin is easy because you can try L-Tryptophan, low doses of 5-HTP and if you’re careful possibly St. John’s wort.
Norepinephrine is a bit of a challenge because it’s a step up from dopamine. So you could try boosting dopamine with Mucuna Pruriens or L-Tyrosine and hope for the best. See if they work. Otherwise, spend some time searching Nootropics Expert for all the nootropics that positively affect norepinephrine. Valerian comes to mind. And I’m sure you’ll find others.
This will likely take a combo of 4 – 5 nootropics to achieve what you are looking for. And plenty of trial and error.
Hello, I have come across your site when researching a supplement I am taking and have been on it for hours reading all the great information. I have been searching for years for the right information to help my situation and hopeful this is it.
I am 49 year old, female and have a long history of depression and ADD. I was even possibly diagnosed with Bipolar II as well in the past. I have tried a few different antidepressants, but never really stick with them for the side effects. I even caused myself some harm with taking Wellbutrim and 5htp which gave me a seizure. Although upon more examination with EEG’s a underlying seizure disorder may have always been there and my history of frequent falls may have had an answer. I was put on Depakote for about 2 years until I was tired of the weight gain and other side effects. My EEGs were normal and was weaned off the depakote – that was 2010.
I recently tried Prozac but started to gain weight again and it did not seem like it worked as well as it did in the past.
At the present I have been trying several supplements and lot of them you have mentioned. This is what I am using. I still try and through 5 htp in with this mix, not sure why I keep trying this – but I guess I keep hoping it will help.
In AM:
DL- Phenylalanine 750mg
L tyrosine 500mg
B6 100mg
Vitamin B complex Total 460mg By Nutricost
Contains Vit C, B1, B2,B3, B6, B9, B12 Methyl and B7, Inositol, Choline Bitartrate
5htp 100mg – some days
After Breakfast:
Theanine Serene with relora – GABA 500mg, Taurine 450mg, L theanine 200mg, Holy Basil leaf extract 100mg
Korean Ginseng 300mg + Ginko Biloba 160mg
Vitamin C 1000mg
Vitamin D3 5000IU
At bedtime:
GABA Soothe – GABA 100mg, theanine 100mg, Sensoril (ashwaganda) 225mg
L tryptophan 1000mg
Magnesium Glycinate chelated 400mg
At times, though I hate to, I add a nighttime allergy with chlorpheniramine and phenylephrine because my boyfriends snoring messes with my sleep.
So hoping you can see my regimen and give some tips.
Suzanne, so far it looks like you are on the right track. How are these stacks working for you and what still needs improvement?
Hello David
Is there any place in Europe where i can buy Aniracetam?
I can only find it in US, and with tax, costum and shipping to Denmark. Makes it impossible
Regards
Johnny Haugaard
Johnny, regulations seem to vary from country to country within the EU. But I didn’t come across anything specifically mentioning Aniracetam in my research. Please let us know what you find out.
Hi Johnny,
I bought mine on ebay.
*thumbs up* I would’ve done this, but my pills are higher mg, so next time I buy them I will get smaller. 🙂
Hello David!
I’m new to the world of nootropics and I’m trying to treat depression and bipolar disorder without prescription medications.
I’m trying to achieve a more balanced and consistent life in regards to mood. For me, it is extreme ups and downs. The seesaw from one end to the other changes fast.
I strongly related to the following about serotonin:
When you have adequate serotonin levels in your brain and it’s working properly, you’ll be confident, easy-going, flexible, happy, and positive. (I admit, I’m the opposite of all of these things when I am “down” and boardline arrogant when I’m “up”. I wish I realized all of this about myself sooner, but I always blamed a current situation and am now seeing the long term pattern.)
Serotonin deficiency can result in you becoming depressed, irritable, obsessive, negative and worried.
This list is extensive and has a lot of great effects for each nootropic. I wish I could take them all because they all seem to help brain function in one way or another, but I doubt that would be sensible or even affordable for me, so how do I break these 12 down into a stack that I should take?
– Which ones work best when combined?
– Which one(s) should I start with?
– How do I figure out which ones would work best for my symptoms?
Definitely try magnesium, lithium, selenium, and vitamin D, plus whatever else David might suggest.
Michael, it’s a great question but also highlights why it is so difficult to recommend a nootropic stack for something like depression. Because it often takes a lot of experimenting until you hit the sweet spot for you.
I’d suggest starting with the basics including the vitamins and minerals mentioned in this post. At the dosage recommendations in the original review for each of these. Not on this list but often works well for mood disorders is Lithium Orotate: https://nootropicsexpert.com/lithium-orotate/
Then add something to boost serotonin, dopamine and acetylcholine. That could include L-Tryptophan (serotonin), L-Tyrosine (dopamine) and CDP-Choline (acetylcholine).
For now, you don’t know exactly what’s going on in your brain. But with this stack, if you start to see improvements then you’ll know you’re on the right track. If you find some symptoms are less but you’re more irritable for example, then you may have too much norepinephrine. So you’d cut back on the L-Tyrosine. In other words, listen to your body for the subtle differences. Instead of using a broad stroke like “depression”.
I’d also consider adding an adaptogen which works to help balance things out in your brain. Bacopa may be a good one to try.
Thank you so much for getting back to me!
You are honestly awesome for being here to answer questions like mine. Thank you so much for taking the time out of your day to do this.
I will let you know how things work out!
After a while of taking my stack, I’ve been doing great in terms of mood balance and depression management. So thank you! This stuff really does work. I’m taking:
– L-Tyrosine
– L-Tryptophan
– CDP-Choline
– Bacopa
– Magnesium L-Threonate
– Fish Oil
– Taurine
– Vit D
– B-Complex
– Occasional L-theanine and Caffeine
However, I’m having a problem 2-5pm with sluggishness. My mind is alert and energized, but my body and muscles ache and feel tired. I haven’t found a way to prevent this yet. I take my stack in the morning, and some of again them before bed.
I’m thinking of taking something in the afternoon to prevent a crash, but I’m unsure what I should use. Acetyl L-Carnitine perhaps?
Michael, I’d split your dose of the entire stack so you take half in the morning and half again at noon. But make sure your dosages are high enough and based on the recommended dosage in each nootropic review here on Nootropic Expert.
Then at noon I’d add ALCAR, L-Tyrosine (or NALT) and try your L-Theanine+caffeine stack either at noon or mid-afternoon.
Magnesium however should be taken about 90 mins. before bed.
How do you split doses with powder gel capsules?
Robert, not sure I understand your question. But if you mean half of a 500 mg capsule and you need 250 mg then you open the capsule and dump half of it out. Or onto a plate or something for use next time.
You should probably include selenium as a nootropic. I noticed decreased thoughts of suicide when I was taking it, and they came back when I stopped taking it. Thanks.
John, selenium is on my list of supplements to review. So thanks.
Hi
I have bipolar and OCD.
I’ve been in a depressive state for some time now.
Tianeptine has worked wonders.
You have this long list above.
I have used some in the past.
Can you tell me the best ones on the list? The most sought after?
The strongest?
I know you may say that every person is different therefore I can’t tell you.
But please, what is the strongest and best besides Tianeptine which I love.
Tianeptine is just not doing enough right now.
There must be some that are especially good.
I am sort of desparate
What do you take, or what is the most common one, or most
common stack?
Phenibut does not work for me. Aniracetam not either.
Thank You for now.
Jon
Jon, if Tianeptine has worked for you the I suggest first learning everything you can about how it works in your brain. You can use this: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tianeptine. See the “Pharmacology” section.
Next, find nootropics that work on each of what Tianeptine does in your brain. Including boosting serotonin, BDNF, action on NMDA and AMPA receptors and boosting dopamine. I’m not aware of any nootropic that works directly on μ-opioid receptors.
This will take some work but you’ll end up with a nootropic stack that’s safer and you can use long-term without tolerance. This is not a “one pill” solution.
Hello David
I’m in a desperate way.. I came off psy drugs cold turkey 3 months ago after 20 years on them (drs did it as nothing helped anymore & I became intolerant), but I’m suffering massive suicidal depressive fluctuations, anxiety, confusion, panic attacks, mood swings, headaches, some times manic type stuff, blurred vision, sometimes anger.. I also have the sensation that the entire frontal lobe of my brain has gone numb/swollen/stopped functioning.. all this is accompanied with atrocious physical pains, constant cramps, nausea, chest pains & so much more.
I have no idea how much of all of this is protracted withdrawal symptoms which could take a year or a brain disfunction or something else.. all I know is I feel like I’m dying.. I’ve bought & tried so many supplements & products that it’s ridiculous.. but without guidance I don’t know what I’m doing, & may even be either worsening the problem, worsening withdrawal symptoms or even potentially putting my life into danger..
I even attempted taking an experimental drug called NSI-189 for 3 days but I think it made me worse & stopping it made me much much worse.. I’ve contacted drs, people, companies that sell me products, hospitals, er.. everyone.. I get different advice from different people..
Right now I stopped everything except omega 3 high does epa/dha content but it’s not helping much.. please, can I give you a list of everything I have by pm.. I’d really appreciate your advice as to what I should take, or not take & for how long.. It seems to much stimulants make me hyper/aggressive, notably to much seratonine..
to much of certain other neurotransmitters also worsen my anxiety & products that boost dopamine short term (for a few hours) have crash effects & thus make me more depressed & aggressive after a few hours.. in fact anything that has a short term effect makes me fluctuate worse..
Please help, I’m desperate & don’t know where to turn. Please contact me by email if this post is too long to be posted.. thank you.
Jason, first and I hate to tell you something you likely already know. You can’t quit taking antidepressant meds ‘cold turkey’ after prolonged use. Likely the best advice I can give you right now is contact Dr. Kelly Brogan (https://kellybroganmd.com/). She helps people titrate safely off of antidepressant and antianxiety meds. Abruptly quitting these types of medications is very dangerous.
I’m not a doctor and don’t even play one on TV. So please work with someone like Dr. Brogan and get at least somewhat stable again. And then we can start experimenting with nootropic supplements. And find the right stack for you.
Have you looked into kratom? do you have any experience or opinion on this plant?
Robert, I’ve several years of experience with Kratom and use it daily for pain. My wife uses it for mood and sleep. Different strains work for different things and it takes a lot of trial and error to find what works.
Quality is also critical and finding the right vendor takes some doing. I just hope the American Kratom Association can convince the regulators to keep it legal in this country.
Hi, I really appreciate the list of nootropics, but how do I get them all and in what dosages? Is the one pill that has them all (in the right dosage)? I would like to try them and go the natural way an=bout depression but nothing sofar has worked or not consistently.
What do you suggest?
Thanks, Gabriella
Gabriella, unlike what the big pharmaceuticals would like us to believe, there is no “one pill” solution. And it’s not possible to create an effective nootropic stack for depression because there are so many potential causes.
I recommend reading this post again and see if anything resonates with you. Is your depression caused by problems with dopamine, or serotonin, or inflammation? I realize there is no way to tell for sure. So to get started you’ll have to experiment with various nootropic supplements until you find the ones that work for you.
Each nootropic mentioned in this post has a live link through to a complete review of that supplement. Including recommended dosages, side effects, prescription drug interactions and more.
Start with the basics like magnesium and the B-Vitamins. And try one or two supplements like Bacopa Monnieri, Mucuna Pruriens or Kava. Other than the basic vitamins and minerals, try only one or two at a time. Because if you find something that makes you feel better, you’ll want to know what is providing that effect. Which is difficult to do when you are using too many supplements at once.
Hi sir,
It’s 3 years that I suffer from IBS and 2 years I’m suffering from severe depression and generalized anxiety. I’ve tried SSRI’s but i’ve immediately stopped because they worsen my IBS symptoms. So i am very interested in using nootropics like ashwagandha,ginseng,bacopa,rhodiola ecc.. Could you please tell me what would be the best combination and does exist any supplement whith good organic combination of these adaptogens?? Thank you
Ted, I’m not aware of a combination of these herbs specifically for depression. And even it there was I wouldn’t trust it until you find out what works for you. You know your body better than anyone. So I suggest you carefully read each review and see if anything resonates with you. Find a trusted brand and try them one at a time. That is the only way to isolate and find out what works for you without side effects.
Once you read through each review, find that supplement on a site like Amazon that has a lot of reviews and read through them. You’ll be amazed what may turn up with someone dealing with issues similar to yours sharing how it worked for them.
I realize this will take time and effort. But you need to put the time and investment in if you want to get better. It took me 3 years of experimenting until I felt better. So know what you are going through to a certain extent.
thank you sir
Hi Sir
Can i use tianeptine with St john’s wort. As tianeptine is not a an SSRI and is not a classical TCA antidepressant
Japneet, I highly recommend that you NOT combine St. John’s wort with tianeptine. The potential is irregular heart beat or heart attack. With the possibility of convulsions, hyperthermia and death.
Hi David – Researching the best nootropics for what I need has proven to be confusing and exhausting as I continually read conflicting information on blogs and ‘authoritative’ sources.
I’m wondering about hordenine and if there is a reason it wasn’t included on your above list? It apparently acts as an MAO inhibitor. I have been taking SSRI’s for many years with some benefit in mood but I have seen the most helpful affects from meds that increase dopamine (for motivation) so I’m looking for nootropics that help with either increasing production or inhibiting breakdown, of dopamine – I’m not sure which action is best at this point.
Thank you for any help.
Hordenine is on my list and haven’t gotten to it yet. If you are looking for monoamine oxidase inhibitors, please see the individual review for Methylene Blue, Rhodiola Rosea, Ginkgo Biloba, Berberine, Oat Straw and Turmeric (curcumin) which are, or act as MAOI’s.
You can also boost dopamine by using NALT or Mucuna Pruriens.
Each of us responds differently to the nootropics I’ve listed here. The key is experimenting one by one until you find the one, two or three that work best for you. The best approach is usually building a small nootropic stack for something like catecholamine-based depression.
Last suggestion is click on the “Blog” link above in the menu and scan down the list of posts. Most of them either have a recommended stack or several suggestions on what to try.
I take it that for treating depression St John’s Wort shouldn’t be used with NooCube?
Each NooCube capsule contains:
Alpha GPC
Cat’s Claw
Oat Straw
Huperzine A
Bacopa Monnieri
L-Theanine
L-Tyrosine
Becky, the biggest concern with St. John’s wort is Serotonin Syndrome. Please see this section of my St. John’s wort review here > https://nootropicsexpert.com/st-johns-wort/#st-johns-wort-and-serotonin-syndrome
If you are not using any other prescription medication, St. John’s wort ‘may’ be safe with NooCube. I say “may be safe” because I do not know how much of each nootropic is used in the NooCube formula. I could not find the exact dosage of each ingredient. So there is no way to tell if the nootropics in their formula that boost serotonin increase it to unsafe levels when combined with St. John’s wort.
hi,
I am 24 dealing with major depression and addiction. I am currently on 200 mg of Wellbutrin and deplin. I just starting reading about nootropics and I am thinking about purchasing Aniracetam. Does anyone have any ideas? I cannot get out of bed, see my friends, or do anything. I feel like a loser and committing suicide every day. Anything would help. Thank you
Brandon, Aniracetam may help but it may not be the best place for you to start with nootropic supplements. Please carefully read the full review for each of these and consider trying them:
https://nootropicsexpert.com/vitamin-d/
https://nootropicsexpert.com/lithium-orotate/
https://nootropicsexpert.com/dha/
I realize that DHA, Vitamin D and Lithium Orotate are not ‘sexy’ and seem tame by comparison to potent prescription antidepressants and some of the racetams. But you may be pleasantly surprised. Because sometimes we can correct major health issues simply by correcting imbalances in our body and brain.
When fundamentals including certain vitamins, minerals and phospholipids get out of whack it can seem like our world is coming to an end. And truth be told, if left unchecked, it will come to an end. For proof of this all you need to do is read some of the studies done over the last 100 years for lithium.
Did you know that “Deplin” is just an expensive pharmaceutical version of Vitamin B9 (folate)? Doctors prescribe it to boost folate in your body when regular antidepressants are not working as designed. What that tells me is the B-Complex vitamins are essential for normal mood and memory. And absolutely required to synthesize all the major neurotransmitters including acetylcholine, dopamine, norepinephrine, epinephrine, serotonin, and melatonin.
Sounds good.
Yeah, Cymbalta is a especially difficult to get off of. There are many sites devoted to it. Ive cut 30% so far at 1% per day. Its a long process but better safe then sorry.
I decided to go with Alpha GPC (Choline) 99% pure from healingtreeoflife and Aniracetam powder from nootropicsdepot.
If im taking 750mg Aniracetam twice a day with a spoonful of coconut oil how much Choline do i take with each dose… 500mg?
Try 500 mg of Alpha GPC (or whatever the capsule size is) each time you dose Aniracetam. And see how you feel. If you start feeling fatigued you know you’re getting too much choline. Cut the dose in half if that happens. It’s good to know the Alpha GPC is “99% pure” because many manufacturers cut it by 50% with a filler to prevent it from liquefying.
Hi Robert,
I also had a big problem weaning off of Cymbalta – the first time, experiencing a month-long headache even after getting down to 5 “balls” of the medication (from inside the capsule) per day before stopping.
By the next time I had to wean off Cymbalta, I’d learned about 5-HTP. Although Dave is correct that it’s best to be cautious, I got back down to the “5 balls” per day and then one day, just stopped all Cymbalta and started taking 50mg 5-HTP (once daily) instead. Worked wonders! No headache or other withdrawal, and similar anti-depressant effects. Since it’s a precursor to melatonin AS WELL AS serotonin, best to try this for the first time on a weekend or some other time when you are sure you don’t have to operate heavy machinery, take a test, etc. as some people are made quite sleepy by it if they are melatonin-deficient. I realize this is an old post, but just wanted to share in case you’re still searching (or for others).
Ouch… looks like Choline, Ginseng & Rhodiola Rosea all affect Serotonin levels. Looks like im stuck until ive completely weaned off the cymbalta… unless i can safely get started with something once im down to a very low dose?
Robert, you shouldn’t have any problem with the various choline supplements and Cymbalta. But I would stay away from Ginseng and Rhodiola. Because either of those could influence serotonin enough to possibly cause Serotonin Syndrome.
Once you’re down to a very low dose of Cymbalta, I’d still use caution because who knows who long this stuff stays in your system to cause problems. Just not worth messing around with. SSRI’s and MAOI’s are very potent pharmaceuticals. And SSRI’s are especially difficult to quit because of the withdrawal symptoms. I strongly advise finding an osteopath or naturopathic doctor who has the knowledge to walk your through this.
David,
Very informative site. I took Lexapro for 10 years for social anxiety and depression and then Cymbalta for 2 when the Lexapro stopped working. I am currently weaning off Cymbalta at 1% a day. I’ve done a fair bit of research on beneficial supplements and added them to my diet. Recently I’ve been reading about microdosing mushrooms for treating depression and I’m starting to learn about nootropics. Can you recommend a nootropic stack?
Thanks,
Rob
Robert, recent research shows that depression is likely caused by inflammation. And that is one of the reasons Cymbalta works. By creating a decrease in proinflammatory cytokine activity and an increase in anti-inflammatory cytokines. So look for nootropics to replace Cymbalta with something natural that affects neurotransmitters and reduces inflammatory cytokines.
Ginseng provides these benefits. You can read the whole story here > https://nootropicsexpert.com/ginseng/. But play special attention to the right type of Ginseng and getting a quality supplement that will actually work.
You also need a high quality, bio-available B-Complex formula. Using folate (NOT folic acid) and methylcobalamin (NOT cyanocobalamin). You also require Vitamin D and Magnesium to make the neurotransmitters you need. See the review for each here on Nootropics Expert so you understand how they work.
That will get you started. I’d also investigate Rhodiola Rosea here > https://nootropicsexpert.com/rhodiola-rosea/. And possibly Aniracetam which I’ve found to be one of the best antidepressants I’ve ever used. But keep in mind that what works for me may not work for you. It’ll take some trial and error on your part. And patience.
One last thing … as long as you are using Cymbalta, pay special attention to nootropics that ‘directly increase serotonin’. And DO NOT USE THEM! You must avoid Serotonin Syndrome or you could get into a load of trouble.
Thanks for the info…
Good news is I already take Methyl Folate, methylcobalamin, vitamin D and magnesium. I’ll definitely look into the rest.
I’ve read about serotonin syndrome. As I mentioned I’m weaning off Cymbalta by 1% day. Would you recommend waiting until completely off before starting something like Aniracetam or do you think it would be safe once I’m down to a very low dose?
Aniracetam shouldn’t be a problem. I’ve flagged all the nootropics that could cause Serotonin Syndrome in each of the reviews. Look for it in either dosage notes or side effects for each.
8/26/17
David …
Just happen 2 find your ‘great’ nootropicsexpert website …
Very impressed with your fully detailed product summaries …
Am currently reviewing ‘depression’ summary …
Adding niacin powder to ‘Emergen-C’ electrolyte drink @ 4-5 a.m. wakeup really wonders on my brain …
Begin to feel incredible ‘effect’ in my scalp/brain area starting within 2 minutes after entering bloodstream …
Then drift off into sleep without realizing that I in fact did …
Will probably follow up with future emails for your professional advice …
Keep up the good work!!!
CWHEIL
Minnesota
Chuck, you touched on a very good point and one that is often missed in the biohackers and nootropics community. And that point is that most of us are literally starved for the vitamins our body and brains need to function. We do not get them from our food supply. No matter how healthy we try to eat. The nutrients are just not there in factory-farmed food today. And the amount of toxins we’re exposed to everyday is crazy. Further depleting what vitamin stores we managed to accumulate along the way. Thanks for the compliment and enjoy Nootropics Expert!
David,
I’m a 53 year old male w 25 years diagnosed w severe clinical depression w/anxiety and now ADHD this year.
Issues with executive functioning skills. Tested low.
Hate Aderall. What in your opinion should I research as the best stack for me to help my brain & its many disorders. Including memory loss due to repeated concussions.
Thank you,
Mark
Mark, it would be helpful to know why you hate Adderall. I do as well and use Ritalin instead. These two stimulants work differently in the brain. And I found Ritalin works better for me. I did an experiment last year for personal reasons and discontinued use of Ritalin altogether (for an entire year). I used the stack you’ll find near the top of this page > https://nootropicsexpert.com/best-nootropics-for-adhd-add/. It’s right under the sub-title “Adult ADD Nootropic Stack”. Mind Lab Pro was key to making that stack work. But it worked very well.
I did go back on (a lower dose) of Ritalin because I too have big issues with Executive Function. The stimulant works to help executive function. But it needs the support of the rest of that same stack to work efficiently. And eliminate side effects.
The combination of Aniracetam and Sulbutiamine works great for the depression I deal with. It’s not severe depression but it may be worth a try for you.
For anxiety, please see this post > https://nootropicsexpert.com/best-nootropics-for-social-anxiety/. One of the things I’ve learned is anxiety is often caused by excess norepinephrine. One of the best ways to counter that is with this > https://nootropicsexpert.com/lithium-orotate/. Lithium has a bad rap because it’s been used for decades to treat bipolar disorder and mania. I’ve found in my case it works beautifully to tame spikes in aggression and rage type feelings. They don’t happen often for me but micro-dosing lithium stops it within 15 minutes.
It’ll take some trial and error because each of use is unique. Those posts should get you started. Along the way you may find like I did that you need more dopamine. Especially at your age. So I use Mucuna Pruriens (L_DOPA). But have to amp up my serotonin. So I use small doses (25 mg) of 5-HTP which is a direct precursor to serotonin.
And for traumatic brain injury, that’ll be my next article. So please make sure you’re subscribed to the list so you’ll get an email when it’s published. Should be in the next week or so. Please report back on how you’re doing.